Skip to content
+90 531 883 33 88
← Back to the list of updates

Court decision · Title Cancellation and Registration Cases

Constitutional Court Annuls the Market Value Rule in Pre-emption: What Happens in Pre-emption Actions Until August 6, 2027?

The Constitutional Court has annulled the rule in Article 734(2) of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK) providing that, in pre-emption (önalım / şufa) actions, the price of the share is determined by the court on the basis of market value (rayiç değer). The annulment will enter into force on August 6, 2027; the right of pre-emption and the time limits for filing an action continue to apply.

Prepared by
Av. Umut Güneş
First published
November 7, 2026
Source
Constitutional Court

KEY POINTS

At a Glance

Which issue was assessed?

Article 734(2) of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK), as amended by Article 36 of Law No. 7571, required the holder of the right of pre-emption (önalım hakkı), in order to take over the share, to deposit in cash, within the firm deadline (kesin süre) granted, the market value (rayiç bedel) determined by the court and the title deed costs borne by the buyer. The Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi) reviewed the constitutionality of this rule upon objection applications (itiraz başvuruları) and an annulment action.

What did the court decide?

The phrase “market value” in TMK Art. 734/2 was annulled. The other provisions of the same paragraph, which could no longer be applied, and the second paragraph of Transitional Article 1 of the TMK were also brought within the scope of the annulment under Article 43(4) of Law No. 6216. The annulment provisions will enter into force on August 6, 2027, nine months after November 6, 2026, the date on which the decision was published in the Official Gazette (Resmî Gazete).

What is the reasoning of the decision?

According to the Court, the statutory pre-emption relationship is based solely on the buyer being replaced while the terms of the sale are preserved. A market value to be determined later, instead of the amount in the sales contract, may result in unjust gain or loss for the buyer and leaves the holder of the right of pre-emption uncertain about the amount they will have to pay; a fair balance has not been struck between the parties’ interests arising from the right of ownership.

What are the scope and limits of the decision?

The statutory right of pre-emption and the preclusive periods (hak düşürücü süreler) in TMK Art. 733 were not annulled. The current provision remains in force until August 6, 2027. The decision does not result in the automatic refund of deposited amounts, the setting aside of final judgments or the automatic return of the old sale price rule; the procedural stage of each file should be assessed separately.

Güneş & Güneş corporate news cover on the Constitutional Court’s decision E.2026/23, K.2026/162 annulling the market value rule in pre-emption

The Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi — AYM) has annulled the provision requiring that the market value (rayiç bedel) determined by the judge be taken as the basis in right of pre-emption (önalım / şufa) actions. The decision was published on November 6, 2026; the annulment provisions will enter into force on August 6, 2027. So what changes for co-owners and for pending cases? [1] [3]

The decision at a glance: What was annulled?

The Constitutional Court (AYM) annulled the phrase “market value” (“rayiç bedeli”) in the second paragraph of Article 734 of Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 (Türk Medenî Kanunu — TMK), on the grounds that it is incompatible with the obligations relating to the protection of the right of ownership in the context of Articles 5 and 35 of the Constitution. The other provisions of the same paragraph, which could no longer be applied as a result of this annulment, and the second paragraph of Transitional Article 1 of the TMK were also brought within the scope of the annulment (Law No. 6216, Art. 43/4). [1] [2]

Important: The statutory right of pre-emption has not been abolished. What was annulled is the scheme introduced by Law No. 7571 for determining the price and making the deposit when this right is exercised. The annulment provisions will enter into force not on the day the decision was published, but nine months later. [2]

Which provision on the pre-emption price had changed?

The amendment to TMK Art. 734/2, which entered into force on December 25, 2025 under Article 36 of Law No. 7571, required the holder of the right of pre-emption, in order to take over the share, to deposit in cash, within the firm deadline (kesin süre) granted, the market value determined by the court and the title deed costs borne by the buyer. The second paragraph of Transitional Article 1 provided that this new price scheme would also apply to actions filed before the amendment. [1]

In the earlier text of the law, by contrast, the pre-emption price was based on the price in the sales contract and the title deed costs borne by the buyer. This historical comparison does not mean that the old text automatically comes back into force as a result of the annulment decision.

Why did the Constitutional Court find the market value method unconstitutional?

The Constitutional Court stated that a sale concerns three separate interests: the owner selling their share, the third party purchasing the share, and the co-owner wishing to exercise the right of pre-emption. According to the Court, the statutory pre-emption relationship is based solely on the buyer being replaced while the terms of the sale are preserved. [1] [2]

Taking as the basis a market value to be determined later by the court, instead of the amount agreed in the sales contract, may alter this economic balance. Paying the third-party buyer an amount different from the sale price may, depending on the specific circumstances, result in unjust gain or loss for the buyer. The holder of the right of pre-emption may also be unable to know with certainty in advance how much they will have to pay at the end of the proceedings. [2]

For these reasons, the Constitutional Court concluded that a fair balance had not been struck between the parties’ interests arising from the right of ownership. The decision also contains dissenting opinions (karşıoy) to the effect that market value could protect the buyer under inflationary conditions; nevertheless, the binding outcome is the majority’s annulment ruling. [1]

When will the decision enter into force?

The decision was published in Official Gazette (Resmî Gazete) No. 33422 of November 6, 2026. The Constitutional Court deferred the entry into force of the annulment provisions by nine months. Accordingly, the date on which the annulment enters into force is August 6, 2027. [3]

Until that date, the provision remains in force. It is not correct to interpret the annulment decision as meaning that, as of November 7, 2026, the market value system immediately became inapplicable in all pre-emption actions. Announcing an annulment and its entry into force are not the same act.

Which points should be examined in pending pre-emption actions?

In pending actions, in particular the date of the sale, the date on which the action was filed, the notification through a notary, the determination of the price, the interim decision on the deposit, the amount deposited and the records of accrued interest (nema) should be assessed together. The transitional provision governing the application of the December 25, 2025 amendment to actions filed in the past is also within the scope of the annulment; however, the entry into force of this annulment ruling has likewise been deferred until August 6, 2027. [1]

It cannot be said that amounts deposited earlier are automatically refunded, that final judgments are automatically set aside, or that all files revert to the old deposit procedure. The current procedural stage of each file, the interim decisions on the firm deadline and any new legislation that may be enacted in the future should each be monitored separately.

Checklist for co-owners, buyers and sellers

  • Co-owner holding the right of pre-emption: Notification and the preclusive period (hak düşürücü süre), the interim decision on the deposit obligation, existing payment and accrued interest records.
  • Third party purchasing the share: The actual sale price in the contract, payment documents, valuation report, claims regarding a price difference and the stage of the proceedings.
  • Selling co-owner: The date of the sale, its legal nature, the record of co-ownership in shares (paylı mülkiyet) and the terms of the transaction between the parties.

Have the right of pre-emption and the time limits for filing an action been abolished?

No. The decision did not annul TMK Art. 732, which governs the right of pre-emption, or TMK Art. 733, which governs the preclusive periods for exercising the right. Under the time-limit regime amended by Law No. 7571, the three-month period following notification through a notary and the one-year upper limit running from the date of sale are assessed separately. For sales before December 25, 2025, a separate examination may be required with respect to the transition and the previous two-year upper limit. [1]

The annulment decision concerning the pre-emption price is not a decision that extends the time limit for filing an action or restarts time limits that have already run.

Will there be a direct return to the old sale price rule after August 6, 2027?

No definitive answer can be given to this today. The Constitutional Court annulled the TMK Art. 734/2 regime established by Law No. 7571 and granted the legislature a nine-month period to enact new legislation. It cannot be assumed that the old text automatically returns unchanged as a consequence of the annulment decision. [1]

The legislature may adopt a new price and deposit regime. If no new legislation is enacted, the procedures and principles by which the legal gap that may arise after the annulment will be filled in specific disputes should be assessed separately.

Frequently Asked Questions

Has the Constitutional Court completely abolished the right of pre-emption (şufa)?

No. The annulment concerns not the existence of the right of pre-emption but the price determination and deposit scheme amended by Law No. 7571.

Is market value no longer applied today?

The entry into force of the annulment ruling has been deferred until August 6, 2027. As of November 7, 2026, the current provision is in force.

Will the amount deposited in old pre-emption actions be refunded?

The annulment decision does not by itself result in an automatic refund for all files. The stage of the specific action, the deposit decision and the procedural situation should be examined.

Have the three-month and one-year time limits in pre-emption actions changed?

This Constitutional Court decision did not annul the time-limit provisions in TMK Art. 733. The transitional provisions should be addressed separately depending on the date of the transaction.

Will there definitely be a return to the sale price basis on August 6, 2027?

No such automatic outcome can be stated. Any new legislation that may be enacted before that date and the post-annulment practice should be monitored separately.

Official decision and related publications

[1] Constitutional Court — E.2026/23, K.2026/162, July 16, 2026 (Decisions Information Bank — Kararlar Bilgi Bankası; constitutional review of norms). View the source

[2] Constitutional Court — Decision on the rule providing for the court to determine the price of the share subject to the right of pre-emption on the basis of market value, press release ND 22/26 — November 6, 2026. View the source

[3] Official Gazette — November 6, 2026, Issue 33422 — Constitutional Court decision E.2026/23, K.2026/162 (PDF). View the source

Güneş & Güneş: Action for Cancellation and Re-registration of Title Based on the Right of Pre-emption (in Turkish)

Official sources and citation details

Source of the court decision

Court / chamber
Constitutional Court
Decision date
July 16, 2026
File / application number
2026/23
Decision number
2026/162
Date accessed
November 7, 2026
Open the official source

Other official sources

Update and correction notes

There is no substantive correction on record yet. The reason for any change made will be shown here.

This content has been prepared for general information purposes. A separate legal assessment is required depending on the specific circumstances of the case.

Continue in the Knowledge Center

Explore the subject further

These publications are for general information purposes; they do not replace a legal opinion specific to you.

Contact us