Can the seller demand that I vacate the home without returning the money I paid?
The seller can bring a case. But being able to bring a case is not the same as being able to take the home back without payment and without conditions. The sale of a registered residence requires an official form. A private written paper signed by the parties, a bank transfer and the handover of the key do not transfer ownership at the land registry. The same documents can be very valuable as proof that money was given for the purpose of a sale and that the seller allowed the buyer to live there. [1] [2]
The situation discussed here is a private written sale between two private persons, with no transfer at the land registry. It should not be confused with a duly formalized official sale promise. In a prepaid home sale in particular, the law prevents the seller from later invoking the contract’s non-compliance with the required form against the consumer. The rights of a consumer who buys an apartment in a project therefore cannot be determined by looking only at the general rule below. [2] [11]
How is the handover of the key related to the refund of the sale price?
In the 1940 unification of case law decision of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), where the seller who received the price left the property to the buyer’s use, the obligations of return are considered together. If the seller has not returned what was received, the buyer may rely on the right to keep the home until the price paid is returned. In practice this is called the right of retention. Here it means that the buyer may postpone delivery until a specific claim is paid; the buyer does not become the owner this way. If the conditions are met, the court may reserve this right when deciding to prevent interference. [3] [4]
If the person demanding the home is not the person who sold it to me
For example, if you bought the apartment from the title owner’s sibling, proving that you paid the money to the sibling does not by itself show that the sibling was authorized to sell on the owner’s behalf or to receive the price. The chain of transfer, the power of attorney, the owner’s acceptance of the payment and any later approval are examined separately. The buyer’s personal right against the seller cannot automatically be directed at the owner, who was not a party to the sale. A claim for expenses is examined separately. [1] [7]
Will I be paid the old sale price or the home’s present value?
The starting point is not the total price written in the contract but the amount proved to have actually been paid. If years have passed, the court may consider preserving the purchasing power of the money as of the day of payment, depending on the nature of the claim. This is called balancing justice (denkleştirici adalet). The date of each instalment should be stated separately. Demanding back the price of an invalid sale does not automatically entitle you to the home’s present value or to the whole of any increase in that value. Interest, its starting date and earlier payments are also addressed separately. [2] [6]
Under what conditions can ecrimisil be demanded for the period I lived in the home?
Ecrimisil here is compensation claimed for the unlawful use of immovable property in private ownership. It is not rent owed under a lease. The day the key was handed over, the day the permission to use ended and the day the home was returned may not be the same. The seller should specify for which period and on what basis he or she demands payment; the buyer should specify by what right the home was used in that period. [1] [3] [12]
Does ecrimisil necessarily start running after a notice arrives?
No. The sending, service and content of the notice matter; but if the sale price has not been returned, merely saying “vacate my home” does not make the buyer an unlawful occupier in every case. On the other hand, the fact that the buyer paid some amount for the home does not guarantee that no ecrimisil will arise for any period later on. Two decisions show why. [3] [4] [5]
If the refund has really been made and there is no other basis left for using the home, compensation may come into question for the later period during which use continued despite that. A “your money is ready” message, a payment that reached a bank account and a deposit made properly for the buyer’s benefit are not the same thing. Whether the amount is complete and whether there is any condition preventing its withdrawal are examined separately. [2] [3] [4]
2023: An unconditional delivery order cannot be given without protecting the price
In the decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation of March 21, 2023, the informal sale was undisputed, while whether the price had been paid in full was in dispute. The Chamber did not treat the buyer as an unlawful occupier merely because the title had not passed. The regional court of appeal had rejected the ecrimisil claim; the reason for reversal was that an order preventing interference had been made without determining the amount the buyer paid and without granting the buyer a right of retention. In this example both the seller’s ownership and the money paid by the buyer received protection. [4]
2026: Ecrimisil was granted for the period between the notice and the lawsuit
In the March 10, 2026 decision of the same chamber, how much of the price of a duplex had been paid was disputed, and the seller also claimed that part of the home had been rented to third parties. The majority upheld the award of ecrimisil for the period between the service of the notice and the date of the lawsuit, together with the refund of the buyer’s proven payment. The dissenting opinion argued that use cannot be regarded as unlawful before the money received is returned and that the ecrimisil claim should have been rejected. The majority did not establish a general rule that a partial payment or an allegation of subletting is decisive in every case. [5]
For which period and on what rental value is ecrimisil calculated?
First the date on which the unlawful use actually began is determined; then the amount for that period is calculated. For a home, the evidence that can be compared is the real lease contracts of the relevant date for homes of similar size and quality in the same area. Multiplying today’s listing rent by the number of months in the past is not a sound calculation. The condition of the home on that date, the part actually used and the delivery date should be stated. In private-law ecrimisil there is a five-year limitation period counted back from the date of the lawsuit; the defendant may raise this defense in time. Five years does not automatically give the seller five years of compensation. [12]
Can I recover the expenses I made for roof repair and renovation?
The refund of the sale price and the expenses made on the home are two different claims. A possessor in good faith, that is, a person who is justified in believing that he or she has the right to use the home under the circumstances, may claim necessary and useful expenses from the person demanding the return. Until these are met, a right to refuse delivery also comes into play. It matters that the seller handed over the key personally; this permission does not mean that every kind of construction was approved. What the parties knew when the expense was made and what the property needed are examined. [1]
Are a leaking roof, a renewed kitchen and a removable fixture the same?
| Expense | Question to ask in the case | Useful evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Repair to stop a water leak | Was the work necessary to prevent damage to the property? | Photos before the repair, service report, management letter, proof of payment |
| Complete renewal of a working kitchen | Which work gave a lasting benefit; which was merely personal preference? | Before and after condition, itemized invoice, on-site expert examination |
| Removable special fittings | Would removing them damage the property; did the owner offer to pay for them? | Installation record, technical opinion, correspondence about the return |
A possessor in good faith cannot, as a rule, claim the cost of other expenses. However, if the additions made can be separated without damage and the person demanding the return offers no compensation, there is an option to detach and take them before returning. The products obtained are deducted from the expense claim within the conditions of TMK Art. 994. For a possessor who is not in good faith the yardstick is narrower: only expenses that would also have been necessary for the right holder can be claimed. The same invoice should not be written twice, once as an expense and again as an increase in value. [1]
If the roof is a common area of the apartment building
Repair in a detached house and payment for the common roof of an apartment building are not the same case. An apartment building’s roof is, as a rule, a common area. The whole cost of the roof cannot be placed directly on the seller without determining the management decision, the scope of the work, the sharing of costs and the amount the buyer actually paid out of his or her own pocket. Show separately to whom the invoice was issued and from whom the money came. [8]
How are expenses documented before the home is handed over?
For each job follow the order “earlier condition – work done – date – payment – value remaining in the home.” An invoice shows that an expense was made; an on-site inspection can show which property it benefited and to what extent. If the work will be covered up when the home is vacated, or access to the evidence will become markedly harder, the court may be asked for preservation of evidence, explaining the legal interest. Preservation of evidence is not a decision to collect the claim. [1] [9]
What steps are taken if a claim for return of the home and an ecrimisil case arrives?
First read the heading of the document that arrived. A notarial notice is the other side’s demand; a court’s petition and the preliminary examination record show that the proceedings have begun. An owner who wants to have the home vacated on the basis of ownership is usually making a claim for prevention of interference and delivery of the property. If there is a real lease relationship between the parties, the competent court and the procedure to follow may change. [1] [9] [10]
Which court, which time limit, which claim?
In the typical ownership-based case for prevention of interference between two private persons, the competent court is the civil court of first instance; the place where the property is located has exclusive jurisdiction. When only money is claimed, the same jurisdiction rule does not apply automatically. In a transaction between an entrepreneur who sells homes professionally and a consumer, consumer law is examined separately. A dispute does not automatically become subject to rent mediation just because the vacating of a home is demanded; the condition for bringing a case is determined by the nature of the relationship and of the claim. [9] [10] [11]
In the written procedure, the time limit to respond to the lawsuit is, as a rule, two weeks from the service of the petition. If the conditions are met, an additional period may be requested before the first period expires; requesting it does not by itself mean that additional time has been granted. Defending against the ecrimisil claim and demanding collection of a certain amount from the seller are also different things. If an independent payment judgment is sought, the conditions, time limit and fee of a counterclaim, or the option of a separate case, are assessed. A defense of not delivering until the price is paid does not by itself secure a collection judgment. [9]
Which documents should I bring to the first meeting?
| Matter | For the buyer | For the seller |
|---|---|---|
| Sale and payment | Original contract, bank receipts with descriptions, signed receipts | Title and authority records, total price, amounts received and refunded |
| Use and its scope | Handover correspondence, key record, which part was used | Scope of the permission to use, any lease to a third party |
| Demand for return and refund | Notice and proof of service, your reply, payment received in your account | Content and service of the notice, documents showing the price was actually paid or properly deposited |
| Condition and handover of the home | Dated photos, repair record, expense documents, key handover record | Photos taken at handover, number of keys, rental comparables for the relevant period |
A transfer whose link to the sale is unclear does not by itself show the price of the home. An electricity or water subscription supports residence; it does not show on what legal ground the home was occupied. For payment in cash, consider the signed receipt together with the other side’s message accepting the payment. Whether witnesses can be heard depends on the value of the transaction and the rules of proof by written evidence. [9]
An example from Antalya: When should the buyer give back the key?
Suppose that in the Muratpaşa district of Antalya a buyer made two bank transfers for an apartment. The seller handed over the key; the title was not transferred. The buyer took part in a roof repair against water leaks. Three years later the seller said by notary, “Vacate the home within ten days and also pay three years of rent.” This is an example constructed to show the method.
The first thing to look at is not the current rents in the area. Do the receipts show the apartment? Did the seller return the money, or only demand the home? During the three years, did the buyer live in the home, or rent out part of it? Do the management records confirm the share the buyer paid for the roof? The answers change both the ecrimisil period and the payment against which delivery can be demanded. If the parties agree, payment and handover of the key can be tied to the same timetable in a protocol. If there is no agreement on expenses and ecrimisil, the items that remain open are stated. [1] [3] [4] [5] [8]
What should be written in the key handover record?
The address of the independent unit, the date, who hands over and who receives, the number of keys, the condition of the apartment and the payment made that day can be recorded. “I received the keys” and “the parties have no claims left against each other” do not mean the same thing. If the buyer received only part of the price, the buyer should write the amount and his or her statement about the balance; if the seller keeps a claim for compensation for use for a period, the seller should write that period expressly. The record should not make a release on which the parties have not agreed look as if it had been given.
Conclusion
In an informal sale, the key document in the file is sometimes not the title deed record but a single bank receipt showing the refund of the sale price. The title deed shows who the owner is; the payment and handover records show when and on what condition the owner may take the home back. Compensation for past use, the return of the home and renovation expenses are decided separately. The strongest preparation for the buyer is to document every payment and expense; for the seller, to show clearly the scope of the permission and the dates of refund and handover. [1] [3] [4] [5]
Frequently asked questions
Does an informal sale document replace the title deed?
No. For a registered home, a private written document does not transfer ownership by itself. On the other hand, it may explain why the money was given and on the basis of what agreement the key was handed over. [1] [2]
If the seller demands the past years as “rent,” am I considered a tenant?
No. The word used in the notice does not change the relationship. If the key was handed over for the sale, the seller must set out the conditions and the period of the unlawful use he or she alleges. If a lease was really made, the assessment changes. [1] [3] [12]
I have vacated the home; can I still demand the sale price?
The actual handover of the home does not by itself end the monetary claim; but once the home is no longer in hand, there is no longer the possibility of withholding it. Release, settlement, payment and limitation are examined separately. In the refund of an informal sale price, the Court of Cassation has issued decisions that treat the ten-year period as running not from the day of payment but from the date on which a transfer at the land registry can no longer be expected or has become impossible, and that treat the period as not running while the buyer’s possession continues. The general two- and ten-year periods in TBK Art. 82 on unjust enrichment should not be mechanically substituted for this particular practice. [2] [3] [13]
I live outside Türkiye; what should I send first?
First prepare all pages of the document that was served, the record showing the date of service, the district where the property is located and the dated list of payments. State who holds the originals. If the dispute is based on the ownership of the home in Antalya, the location of the property keeps its importance. The address abroad, service of documents and representation are examined separately. [9]
Related reading
- Can the title deed be obtained? Registration and refund of the price in an informal sale
- Ecrimisil case: unlawful use and compensation
- Claim for the price and damages if the title deed cannot be recovered
Sources
- Law No. 4721, Turkish Civil Code — Arts. 3, 683, 705–706, 993–995: ownership, good faith, possession and expenses.
- Law No. 6098, Turkish Code of Obligations — Arts. 77–82, 106–107, 146, 161 and 237: unjust enrichment, limitation and form in the sale of immovable property.
- Court of Cassation, Grand General Assembly, E. 1939/2, K. 1940/77 (1940) — Unification of case law: the seller who does not refund the price, permitted use and mutual return. · Open access
- Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/7093, K. 2023/1669, March 21, 2023 — Informal sale, investigation of the payment and prevention of interference with a right of retention. · Open access
- Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3097, K. 2026/1347, March 10, 2026 — Affirmation concerning ecrimisil after the notice; dissenting opinion based on the reasoning that the price had not been returned. · Open access
- Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2016/524, K. 2017/9222, June 7, 2017 — Purchasing power of the sale price, expenses and ecrimisil in good-faith use. · Open access
- Court of Cassation 1st Civil Chamber, E. 2012/16993, K. 2013/4065, March 21, 2013 — Asserting the personal right arising from the price against an owner who was not a party to the sale.
- Law No. 634, Condominium Law — Arts. 4 and 20: common roof and participation in common expenses.
- Law No. 6100, Code of Civil Procedure — Arts. 2, 4, 12, 127, 132–133, 190, 199–203 and 400 et seq.: jurisdiction, exclusive venue, response, counterclaim, proof and preservation of evidence.
- Law No. 6325, Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes — Art. 18/B: disputes for which mediation is a condition for bringing a case.
- Law No. 6502, Law on Consumer Protection — Arts. 3, 40–41, 73 and 73/A: consumer transaction, prepaid home sale and avenues of application.
- Court of Cassation 8th Civil Chamber, E. 2018/2850, K. 2019/152, January 9, 2019 — The period of ecrimisil in private ownership, the five-year limitation period and comparison with comparable rents.
- Court of Cassation 13th Civil Chamber, E. 2012/25844, K. 2012/26737, November 26, 2012 — The ten-year period in the refund of the price, the impossibility of transfer and continuing possession.