Three documents for the first assessment: the full text of the original application, the refusal letter and the notification record. Further discussions with the administration or repeating the same petition do not by themselves preserve the filing deadline. If there is also an eviction, ecrimisil or tender measure, each should be recorded separately.
My Treasury agricultural land request was refused: what can I do?
The refusal of a request for direct lease or purchase does not mean that all of the applicant’s legal avenues are closed. However, an effective action first requires determining the scope of the refusal measure. The request that was refused, the reason given and the date; the provision on which the application relied; the legal status of the immovable; and the documents in the file must be examined together. The first aim is to preserve the filing period and bring out the real cause of the dispute. Submitting a new petition or talking to the administration does not, by itself, secure that period.
How should you examine the refusal letter?
The date and number of the refusal letter, the notification document and a complete copy of the original application should be placed in the file. If electronic notification was used, the date on which the message was seen should not be treated as the only basis; the legally valid date of notification must be determined separately. If the application petition requested both purchase and lease, it is assessed whether the reply addresses both requests. An explanation of the sale conditions alone does not always show on what grounds the independent lease request was concluded.
The grounds of refusal should be addressed one by one: failure to apply in time, not meeting the period of use, the end of use, not being regarded as an entitled person, the immovable falling outside the scope, and non-performance of the payment obligation call for different examinations. On the other hand, a letter that merely requests documents or states that the review is continuing does not in every case amount to a final and enforceable refusal. The subject of the action is determined by the legal effect of the letter, not by its heading.
Source: Law No. 2577 on Administrative Procedure (İYUK), Arts. 2, 10, 14 and 15.
Which document and legal question answers each ground of refusal?
| Ground of refusal | Priority document | Decisive question in preparing the action |
|---|---|---|
| Date or period of use insufficient | Determination showing the period and the parcel, ÇKS (Farmer Registration System), ecrimisil and cadastral records | Was the date of the correct regime applied; do the records show both the agricultural use and the user? |
| Land not suitable for sale or lease | Title deed, zoning plan, allocation and, if any, coastal/protection documents | Does the alleged obstacle exist on this parcel and does it apply to the type of transaction requested? |
| Application or payment period missed | Original application record, notice, payment plan and notification documents | Can the new possibility under Law No. 7579 be applied; has the filing period for the main action been separately preserved? |
| Applicant is not an entitled person | Documents of the user, tenant, co-owner, heir and representation | Have persons or categories of entitlement been confused? |
The table is a practical guide for assessing the special legislation and procedural provisions below together. Each ground of refusal must be tested against its own parcel, period and applicant.
Which sale or lease regime was applied in the refusal letter?
In an action prepared against a refusal measure concerning Treasury agricultural land, the first question is whether the administration examined the application under the correct legal provision. The fact that the immovable is registered in the name of the Treasury, that it is used for agriculture and that the user has paid ecrimisil for a long time do not, by themselves, show which direct sale or lease route applies. For the same immovable, the conditions for sale and lease may differ. For this reason, in preparing the action the refusal letter, the original application petition, and the title deed and zoning records should be read together.
| Request and basic provision | Main distinction | Point to be reviewed in the refusal measure |
|---|---|---|
| Direct sale: Law No. 6292 Art. 12 and Communiqué No. 355 | Land that, as of 26.04.2012, lies outside the municipal and adjacent-area boundaries, or was later moved outside those boundaries, is considered. For users and tenants, at least three years of agricultural use or lease as of 31.12.2011 is required; co-ownership is assessed separately. | Were the correct date and category of person applied? Were the continuation of the use or lease relationship and the saleability of the immovable investigated? |
| Direct sale: Law No. 4706 Art. 4/12 and Communiqué No. 382 | For land that, as of 26.04.2012, lies within the municipal and adjacent-area boundaries and is unzoned or allocated to agricultural purposes, a period of at least three years as of 30.03.2014 is the basis for users and tenants. Co-ownership is a separate category. | Was the 2011 criterion applied by mistake? Were the historical boundary, the zoning status, co-ownership and the other sale conditions examined separately? |
| Direct lease: Law No. 4706 Additional Art. 6 and Communiqué No. 387 as amended by Communiqué No. 408 | For unzoned land or land allocated to agricultural purposes, at least three years of agricultural use before 31.12.2019 and the continuation of that use are assessed. | Was the ground of refusal relating to sale carried over unchanged to the lease request? Were the current entitlement conditions and any circumstances barring lease investigated? |
Why should the historical municipal boundary and co-ownership be investigated separately?
A document showing today’s municipal boundary does not always explain the past position on which the legislation relies. The boundary decisions in force on the relevant date and the later changes should be obtained for the file. Similarly, it must be determined whether the applicant is merely a de facto user, a tenant, or a co-owner together with the Treasury. Applying the period condition laid down for users to a co-owner without justification may confuse different categories of entitlement. Co-ownership, in turn, does not by itself remove the other conditions that obstruct a sale.
The consequence of this distinction for the action is clear: where an application was refused only because it did not meet the date of use in Law No. 6292, the failure to examine a lease request also put forward under Additional Art. 6 may be made a subject of legal review. However, it must also be shown separately that each alternative request meets its own conditions.
Sources: Law No. 6292, Art. 12; Law No. 4706, Art. 4/12 and Additional Art. 6; General Directorate of National Real Estate (Millî Emlak) — official index of Communiqués No. 355, 382 and 387; Council of State 4th Chamber, E.2025/550, K.2025/2378 — legislation on the sale regime and assessment. As regards the application and payment periods, the 2026 special provision below must also be taken into account.
Is a 2/B application the same as a Treasury agricultural land application?
Although both sale routes are found in Law No. 6292, 2/B areas and Treasury agricultural lands are not subject to the same system of entitlement. For 2/B, the records of the user or the owner of improvements (muhdesat) and the statutory conditions are examined within the framework of Art. 6; for agricultural lands, Art. 12 and the related provisions are examined. The sale of a neighbouring parcel under 2/B does not show that the disputed parcel is of the same nature.
For this reason, merely attaching an example of a neighbouring sale to the case file is not sufficient. The title deed record of the immovable requested, its cadastral history, its legal nature, the documents of use and the statutory category on which the applicant relies must be set out clearly. In assessing the refusal measure, the starting point is the correct classification of the immovable and of the request.
Source: TBMM — the system of Art. 6 and Art. 12 of Law No. 6292. For the current application period, Law No. 7579, Provisional Art. 1 must also be taken into account.
For the related separate dispute: Entitlement to and title deed applications for 2/B lands.
For other disputes concerning the title deed and legal status of the immovable, see the page on real estate law and title deed actions.
Does meeting the conditions for direct lease give an unconditional right to a contract?
Additional Art. 6 of Law No. 4706 allows suitable land to be leased directly to the designated users for up to ten years. It would not be correct to interpret this authorisation to mean that the administration will necessarily conclude a contract whenever use for a certain period is proved. Besides the agricultural nature and continuity of the use, the zoning status of the immovable, whether it is closed to lease because of special legislation, and the other relevant conditions are also assessed.
At the same time, the administration cannot refuse an application without examining it, or on irrelevant grounds, by invoking its discretionary power. In preparing the action it must be explained why the entitlement arises, on which provision the obstacle relied upon is based, and whether that obstacle exists on the specific parcel. The fact that the first-year rent is set on the basis of half of the current year’s ecrimisil charge also does not mean that the same amount applies unchanged in all lease years; the current Communiqué separately provides for increases in later years.
Conditions of sale at the end of ten years of use
What matters for the later sale possibility under Additional Art. 6 is ten years of use in accordance with the contract provisions. It cannot be concluded that the whole period of ecrimisil-based use before the lease is automatically added to this calculation, or that the title deed is automatically transferred at the end of ten years. The tenant must perform its obligations and make a request, and the immovable must be assessed under the relevant sale regime. If a sale application is refused, the review must also cover the lease contract and the performance documents.
Sources: Law No. 7394, Art. 17 — the current first paragraph of Additional Art. 6; Law No. 7143, Art. 17 — ten years of use in accordance with the contract and the later sale provision; Communiqué No. 408 — Official Gazette archive copy. The former first paragraph introduced by Law No. 7143 was amended by Law No. 7394.
New application possibility in 2026: what can be done until 31 December 2026?
As of 20 November 2026, the provision that must be taken into account in the assessment is Provisional Article 1 of Law No. 7579, published on 22.05.2026. The article has extended to 31.12.2026 the application and payment periods specified for Treasury agricultural lands under Article 4 of Law No. 4706 and for immovables under Provisional Article 22, and for sales of 2/B and Treasury agricultural lands under Law No. 6292.
Within the relevant conditions, the provision covers those who did not apply in time, those who did not pay the notified price in time and those who failed to pay more than two instalments when due. However, the new period does not mean that all conditions concerning the saleability of the immovable or entitlement have been lifted. Nor should it be applied to leases under Additional Art. 6 as if it were a general final application date.
The new application period, the filing deadline and the sale price are different matters
The new application possibility granted by the law does not automatically renew the past filing deadline against a previous refusal measure. The scope of an application based on the new statutory provision and the nature of the new measure to be issued must be assessed separately. In addition, the second to fourth paragraphs of Provisional Article 1 contain calculation rules for updating the price. It should not be assumed that the previous sale price will be kept unchanged; the applicable period, the CPI (TÜFE)-based increase and the statutory ceiling calculation must be checked.
Source: TBMM — Law No. 7579, Provisional Art. 1 and entry-into-force provisions; for the publication details, see the Ministry of Justice legislation record.
How is the filing deadline calculated?
Where no special period applies, the period for bringing an annulment action before the administrative court is 60 days. In administrative disputes the period, as a rule, starts the day after written notification. The rules on the last day falling on a holiday and on judicial recess apply separately. For this reason the last day should not be calculated merely by looking at the date on which the refusal letter was drawn up. The notification date, the application records and any measures affecting the period should be shown in a single chronology.
Why should the notification date, the UETS record and the date of learning be examined separately?
It is wrong to build the litigation timetable on the date the refusal letter was issued. First, to whom, by which method and when the letter was notified must be determined. Where the matter is handled through a representative, the rule on notification to the representative is assessed separately. It is not enough to keep only the refusal letter in the file; the notification receipt, the envelope or the evidence records of the electronic notification should also be kept.
Under Law No. 7201, an electronic notification made through UETS (the Electronic Notification Address System) is deemed made at the end of the fifth day following the date it reached the electronic address. The date on which the document was opened must not be confused with this statutory date. An SMS or e-mail alert does not replace the record of the actual electronic notification. In calculating the period, the records of arrival and of being deemed notified should be taken together. By its decision of 17 June 2025, E.2025/137, K.2025/129, the Constitutional Court rejected, by majority, the request to annul the fifth-day rule. The dissenting opinion advocating that early reading be taken as the basis is not the holding of the decision.
In the case of irregular notification, under Article 32 of the Law, the addressee’s learning of the notification and the date of learning the addressee declares are significant. No notification at all, irregular notification and learning of the measure by other means are not the same situation. Earlier petitions concerning learning, delivery receipts or correspondence should be reviewed together with the file. Instead of waiting on the thought that “there was no proper notification”, the start of the period should be assessed on concrete documents.
Sources: Law No. 7201 on Notification, Arts. 7/a, 11 and 32; Constitutional Court, 17.06.2025, E.2025/137, K.2025/129, especially §§ 4–13 and the holding; PTT, electronic notification and evidence records.
What changes if the dispute concerns a tender measure?
Tender measures other than decisions banning a person from tenders may fall within Article 20/A of İYUK. Under this procedure the filing period is 30 days and the Article 11 application does not apply. The refusal of a direct sale or lease request does not turn into a tender dispute merely because it concerns a Treasury immovable. If, besides the refusal measure, there is also a tender for sale to a third party, each measure must be examined under its own period and procedure.
Source: İYUK, Arts. 7, 8 and 20/A.
Can a new application be made to the administration?
İYUK Art. 10: Request for a new measure
When the issuing of an administrative measure is requested under İYUK Art. 10, failure to reply within 30 days results in an implied refusal. If a non-final reply is given within the first 30 days, the applicant may treat that reply as a refusal and bring an action, or may wait for the final reply; the wait cannot exceed four months from the date of application. These periods do not remove the entitlement or application conditions in the special law.
If the administration replies later
If no action was brought, or the action was dismissed as out of time, the law provides a 60-day filing period from the notification of the reply given by the competent authority, after the 30-day period, to an application under Art. 10. This special provision is not a right to unlimited renewal of the period tied to rewriting the same request.
İYUK Art. 11: Request to amend or withdraw an existing measure
A request may be made to the superior authority against the existing measure, or, if there is no superior authority, to the authority that issued it, within the filing period. The application suspends the period. After an express refusal or an implied refusal at the end of 30 days, the period resumes from where it stopped; the days before the application are counted.
Hypothetical example 1: An objection does not give a new 60 days
Suppose an applicant who has let 20 days of the period pass after a refusal measure subject to the general 60-day period makes an Art. 11 application that meets its conditions. When the application is refused, the remaining period is taken as the basis. Waiting on the belief that a full 60-day period starts anew may cause the loss of the right to sue. This example does not represent a real file or a person-specific calculation of time.
Source: İYUK, current Arts. 10 and 11.
If the filing deadline has been missed, is a new application a solution?
Repeating the same request under the same factual and legal conditions does not automatically revive a past filing deadline. A reply that confirms the earlier measure must be distinguished from a decision truly given on a new request. The decision of the Council of State Plenary Session of the Administrative Chambers of 19.10.2020, E. 2020/145, K. 2020/127, is important for this distinction. The decision concerns a dispute over personnel status that was subject to special application periods; it should not be presented as a direct precedent on Treasury land.
Independent lease request and the new statutory possibility
If the previous request concerned only sale, a lease request based on different legal conditions may be assessed separately. However, it must be investigated whether lease had already been requested in the earlier petition, whether it was refused, and whether the new request meets its own conditions. Adding a different statutory article to the petition does not necessarily make the request a new one.
Provisional Article 1 of Law No. 7579 extended the application and payment periods in certain sale regimes until 31 December 2026. An application that falls within the scope and relies on this new provision is different from a mere repetition of the old request. However, the provision is not a general extension for all Additional Art. 6 leases; it does not automatically remove old refusals and does not remove the substantive entitlement conditions.
Hypothetical example 2: The new provision is examined separately
Suppose a person whose purchase application was refused in the past only because of the application period falls within the scope of Law No. 7579. The priority is to apply in time, meeting the conditions of the new statutory possibility. It would not be correct to assume that the past filing period against the old refusal measure is automatically reopened.
Sources: Council of State Plenary Session of the Administrative Chambers (İDDK), E. 2020/145, K. 2020/127; Law No. 7579, Provisional Art. 1.
In which court and against whom is the action brought?
A refusal of pre-contractual entitlement or of a direct lease/sale request, made by exercise of public authority, is assessed under administrative jurisdiction. In actions of this nature concerning immovables and public property rights, territorial jurisdiction is determined by the location of the immovable within the framework of İYUK Art. 34. The performance or termination of an already concluded private-law contract, and independent disputes over title deed and ownership, must be characterised separately.
The decision of the Court of Jurisdictional Disputes (Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi) of 24.11.2025, E. 2025/613, K. 2025/667, held the ordinary courts competent in a dispute over the termination of an agricultural lease contract concluded under Law No. 3083. This decision does not concern the refusal of an initial lease request under Additional Art. 6 of Law No. 4706; it shows the importance of the source of the dispute.
In identifying the defendant administration, the authority, signature and delegation of power in the refusal letter, on whose behalf the measure was issued and the managing authority of the immovable are examined. The mere presence of “Millî Emlak” in the letter does not require the same defendant to be named in every file. The court’s power to examine matters of jurisdiction, venue and defendant does not make care in preparing the action unnecessary.
Sources: İYUK, Arts. 14, 15 and 34; Court of Jurisdictional Disputes, E. 2025/613, K. 2025/667.
The Council of State’s jurisdiction if a provision of the Communiqué is also to be challenged
The dispute may not arise solely from the refusal letter sent to the applicant. If the refusal relies, for example, on a provision of National Real Estate General Communiqué No. 382, the lawfulness of that regulatory provision must also be assessed. In actions against regulatory measures issued by ministries and applicable nationwide, the Council of State has first-instance jurisdiction under Article 24/1-c of the Council of State Law No. 2575. For this reason, it is not enough to name only the administrative court of the place where the immovable is located for all disputes.
İYUK Art. 7/4 gives the person concerned, once a regulatory measure has been applied, the possibility of suing against the regulatory measure, the implementing measure or both together. Where only the annulment of the individual refusal measure is sought, the administrative court is, as a rule, competent; where annulment of the nationwide communiqué provision is also sought, the Council of State’s first-instance jurisdiction is to be borne in mind. In an action directing both claims together, the legal link between the implementing measure and the regulatory provision must be set out clearly.
This possibility does not mean that a new petition creates an unlimited filing period against the communiqué. The existence of a genuine implementing measure, the violation of an interest because of the relevant provision and the conditions of filing in time are examined separately. The fact that the regulatory provision has not previously been annulled does not prevent the annulment of the individual measure based on it. Annulment of the communiqué and annulment of the concrete refusal measure alone are not the same request; the litigation strategy must be built on this distinction.
Sources: Council of State Law No. 2575, Art. 24/1-c; İYUK, Art. 7/4.
If the action was mistakenly brought in the ordinary courts
If an action within the jurisdiction of the administrative courts was brought in the ordinary courts and dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, under İYUK Art. 9 an action may be brought in the competent administrative court within 30 days from the day following the finalisation of the decision on lack of jurisdiction. The date of application to the first court is preserved; therefore it is also examined whether the first action was brought in time for the administrative filing period. The provision does not automatically cure every period missed at the outset. Even if the special 30-day period has passed, where the general administrative filing period has not yet expired, the possibility in Art. 9/2 is assessed separately. One should not wait on the assumption that the file will be transferred automatically.
Source: İYUK, Art. 9.
Who should bring the action? The distinction between user, heir and company
In an annulment action, the violation of an interest is assessed separately from the substantive conditions of the direct sale or lease requested. That the merits of the action can be examined does not necessarily mean that the applicant has acquired a right to sale or lease. The person who made the original application, the addressee of the refusal letter, the de facto user, the tenant under the contract and the person who will bring the action should be compared side by side. Under Arts. 14 and 15 of İYUK, capacity is among the matters of preliminary examination.
For example, the receipts of a family member who pays the expenses of the agricultural holding may not be sufficient unless linked to the identity of the actual user. In an application made in the name of a company, the company’s legal personality must be separated from the personal situation of a partner or manager; the authority to represent must be documented. If the applicant has died, the certificate of inheritance, the earlier application and the usage records should be reviewed together; and it must also be determined whether the relevant special provision allows heirs to continue this right or request. A certificate of inheritance alone does not satisfy all the conditions of sale and lease.
Sources: İYUK, Arts. 2, 3, 14–15 and 26; Law No. 6292, Art. 12. The assessment of user status and entitlement is made according to the special regime to which the application is subject.
For the scope of our work in the field of administrative measures and judicial review, see the page on administrative law, annulment and full remedy actions.
Is having paid ecrimisil enough? What evidence should be prepared?
Ecrimisil does not, by itself, create ownership or a lease contract. A payment document may be assessed, together with other records, as to the period and nature of the use. For this reason, instead of the approach “I have paid for years; the administration must now sell or lease”, it should be shown which condition of the relevant regime each document proves. The period covered by the notice, the immovable number, the surface area and the user’s details should be checked with particular care.
Article 8/2 of Communiqué No. 387, as amended by Communiqué No. 408, provides for the assessment of mutually corroborating data such as use determinations, ecrimisil documents, court and public-institution records, cadastral or land-registration information, aerial photographs and notes in the title deed records. In preparing ÇKS records, irrigation documents and agricultural subscriptions, their link to the specific parcel and the years alleged must be established. General farming activity does not, by itself, prove all dates of use on a particular parcel.
The former ecrimisil debt condition must not be confused with evidentiary value
Communiqué No. 408 removed the former Art. 5/2 of Communiqué No. 387 and the wording on ecrimisil debt in Art. 10/2. The no-debt condition in old brochures should not be carried over unchanged to a current application. This change does not mean that existing public receivables are cancelled. A separate point is the purchase of a neighbouring parcel: this fact may be treated as ancillary; it does not by itself prove by whom and since when the disputed parcel has been used.
Sources: Communiqué No. 408, especially Arts. 3, 5 and 6 — Official Gazette archive copy; Communiqué No. 387 — Legislation Information System.
For the related separate dispute: objection to an administrative ecrimisil notice and annulment action.
Are ecrimisil and rent payments deducted from the sale price?
That a payment proves past use and that it can be deducted from the sale price are different matters. In sales of agricultural land under Article 12/7 of Law No. 6292, in addition to the cancellation of ecrimisil specified in the provision, the set-off against the sale price of ecrimisil and rent actually collected for the last five years, counted from the date of application, is provided for; refund of any part exceeding the sale price is not provided for. This provision is not a general right of refund applicable to every Treasury immovable transaction or to every past payment.
In preparing the calculation, the parcel, the period covered by the accrual, the date of payment, the person who paid, the amount actually collected and the financial result requested should be shown separately. Cancellation of an accrued but unpaid debt, set-off of a paid amount against the sale price and direct refund of money are different requests. Setting the rent on the basis of ecrimisil likewise does not convert earlier occupation into a retroactive lease relationship.
The distinction shown by a Council of State decision: set-off and direct refund
In the decision of the Council of State 4th Chamber of 4 June 2024, E.2023/4845, K.2024/3662, a first-instance dismissal decision, which assessed the matter in terms of a separate action on the ecrimisil accrual and a request for direct refund instead of set-off, was upheld. The rapporteur judge’s proposal for reversal is not the outcome reached by the Chamber. The dispute is in the context of Article 11/6 of Law No. 6292; it therefore cannot be presented as a decision resolving all applications of Article 12/7 concerning agricultural lands. The lesson for a file is to match the financial result requested with the correct provision and with the payment statement.
Sources: Law No. 6292, Arts. 11/6 and 12/7; Council of State 4th Chamber, 04.06.2024, E.2023/4845, K.2024/3662.
For the legal relationships of agricultural production and the holding, see the page on agriculture, greenhouse farming and food law.
Refusal on the five-kilometre ground: sale and lease must be examined separately
In sale practices connected with Art. 12/3 of Law No. 6292, the starting point of the distance criterion on the seaward side is the shoreline (kıyı kenar çizgisi). Measuring the distance to the sea in everyday terms is not sufficient. The sale provision in Communiqué No. 382 is also assessed within this framework. For this reason, if the refusal measure relies on distance, the approved document of the shoreline, its relation to the immovable and the technical basis of the measurement should be examined.
In its decision of 16.04.2025, E.2025/550, K.2025/2378, the Council of State 4th Chamber rejected the request for annulment of the five-kilometre provision in Communiqué No. 382. The decision relied on the reference made by Art. 4/12 of Law No. 4706 to Law No. 6292 and on Art. 12/3 of that Law. The claim that the two-kilometre criterion in the repealed Law No. 4070 should apply was not accepted. In this review, the outcome of the appeal against the decision and its finality have not been verified.
It cannot be said that this sale restriction automatically applies to all leases under Additional Art. 6. On the other hand, the absence of the same general distance obstacle for lease does not render ineffective the coastal legislation, the requirements concerning public service, special protection statuses or other prohibitions on lease. In the action, whether the obstacle cited by the administration genuinely applies to the type of transaction requested should be argued.
Sources: Council of State 4th Chamber, 16.04.2025, E.2025/550, K.2025/2378; for obstacles to lease, Communiqué No. 387 Art. 6.
Can a stay of execution be requested?
Filing an action does not automatically stay the execution of the measure. For a stay of execution, a manifest unlawfulness and damage that would be difficult or impossible to remedy as a result of implementing the measure must be explained together. Claims of loss of harvest, interruption of the irrigation system or end of production should be made concrete with the crop calendar, contracts, determinations and the relevant documents. A general statement of “hardship” does not provide a sufficient basis for assessment.
The refusal measure and the eviction measure must be distinguished
The effect of a negative refusal decision is not the same as the effect of a separately taken eviction, tender or transfer-to-a-third-party decision. An action against the refusal measure does not automatically make another enforceable measure the subject of the action. Interim protection regarding the refusal also does not, by itself, make the applicant a tenant or an owner.
Hypothetical example 3: Refusal and eviction exist together
Suppose a producer whose lease request was refused is also served with an eviction decision. The review must be carried out on the date, reasoning and effect of both measures. Merely seeking annulment of the lease refusal does not in every case provide the legal protection needed against the eviction.
Source: İYUK, Art. 27.
With which documents should the case file be prepared?
The documents should be organised by parcel and period. The application and notification papers may be accompanied by title deed and cadastral information, use determinations, ecrimisil notices and payment documents, ÇKS records for the relevant periods, and irrigation and agricultural electricity records. For each document, the question “which fact does it support, for which period and parcel?” should be answered. Although the age of trees or an aerial photograph may show agricultural activity, they may not by themselves establish who carried it out.
In administrative justice the principle of ex officio investigation applies. For this reason, the administration’s case file and records that the applicant cannot access may be called for and, if considered necessary, an on-site inspection or an expert examination may be requested. However, the court’s power of investigation does not replace the orderly presentation of concrete allegations and the documents available. The period of use, the identity of the user and the legal nature of the immovable are separate matters of proof that complement one another.
How should contradictory records be handled?
Hypothetical example 4: The ecrimisil document shows a different period
Suppose the applicant says they have farmed for a long time, while the ecrimisil document in hand covers only a more recent period. The existence of this document does not by itself prove use in earlier years; nor does its absence mean that all other evidence is worthless. Earlier determinations, changes in parcel numbers, in whose name the records were kept, and the continuity of the agricultural activity should be investigated together. The contradiction should be explained rather than concealed, and it should be made concrete which records are requested from which institutions and for which years. In this way, the request for an on-site inspection and expert examination can also be tied to the specific questions for which answers are sought.
Source: İYUK, Arts. 20 and 31.
The filing deadline must be preserved when requesting access to the case file
The determination or opinion on which the administration relies may not be in the applicant’s possession. Within the framework of Law No. 4982, copies of existing records and of the relevant parts of the application file may be requested. The request should be tied to a specific parcel and application number; the original petition, its annexes, the incoming-document record, the use determinations and the institutional opinions cited in the ground of refusal should be clearly specified. A request for information is not a way of making the administration prepare a new expert report or a special legal analysis; statutory limits on access are also observed.
Merely requesting copies of documents does not automatically suspend the filing period against the refusal of sale or lease. The application and objection periods in an access-to-information dispute and the period against the main refusal measure must be monitored separately. The filing period must not be allowed to pass while waiting for the documents to arrive; the request that the court call for specific documents not in hand should be made concrete.
If the parcel number has changed, or the land has been subdivided or merged, the connection between the old record and the current title deed and cadastral record should be shown. Documents of different parcels in the same location cannot be used in place of one another. Even when taking advantage of a new statutory application possibility, the date and annexes of the old application should be preserved; these records may be needed when reviewing past use and any payment or set-off calculation.
Sources: Law No. 4982, Arts. 7 and 9–13; İYUK, Arts. 11 and 20. Monitoring the periods for document access and against the main measure separately is the procedural consequence of assessing these different application mechanisms together.
How should the prayer for relief of the petition be framed?
The date and number of the refusal measure, the province–district–neighbourhood–block–parcel details of the immovable and the scope of the original application should be stated clearly. The events should be narrated chronologically; allegations concerning the period, entitlement and the nature of the immovable should be kept separate. If sale and lease were requested together, it should be explained which request is the subject of which measure or of the failure to reply. Whether several measures may be challenged in the same petition is assessed separately under the connection conditions in İYUK Art. 5.
The request for annulment, where necessary the request for a stay of execution, the calling for the case file and specific on-site inspection or expert questions should be made concrete. Asking the court to establish a lease contract directly or to transfer the title deed is not the same request as annulment of the refusal measure. Requests concerning litigation costs and attorney’s fees are also governed by the type of action concerned. This framework is no substitute for a ready-made petition in a file whose facts and documents are not yet known.
Source: İYUK Arts. 2, 3, 5, 20 and 27.
On which grounds does the court review the refusal measure?
In an annulment action, the lawfulness of the administrative measure is reviewed in respect of authority, form, reason, subject matter and purpose. Instead of listing each head in the abstract in the petition, a link should be made with the concrete problem in the refusal measure. Applying the wrong statutory date, confusing the applicant’s capacities as user and co-owner, failing to assess the independent lease request, or failing to support the ground of refusal with parcel records may constitute separate allegations.
For example, if the administration found the start of use insufficient, the argument should not be built only on the person having farmed for years. The date of the legislation to be applied, the area actually used, the identity of the user and the records of that period should be set out together. If a zoning or coastal restriction is invoked, it should be shown to which type of transaction the restriction applies and whether it technically covers this parcel. The court does not substitute itself for the administration and review expediency; it examines whether discretion has been exercised within statutory limits.
How does an incomplete application affect the outcome of the action?
The text of the administrative application to be submitted to the court is particularly important. The carrying out of a measure that the applicant did not in fact request cannot be automatically added to the scope of a refusal decision already given. If sale and lease requests were put forward together, the legal basis and the prayer for each request should be separated. Annulment based on an incomplete examination and a finding that the applicant meets all the conditions do not have the same result; the aim of the action and the evidence plan should be built with this distinction in mind.
Source: Law No. 2577 (İYUK), Arts. 2, 3, 14, 20 and 28.
If annulment is ordered, is the land directly leased or the title deed transferred?
An annulment decision does not mean that the court establishes a lease contract or transfers ownership by itself. The administration is obliged to take a measure consistent with the operative part and reasoning of the decision. If the decision rests on an incomplete investigation, it cannot be assumed that the court has conclusively accepted all conditions of entitlement. From which point, and within which legal limits, the review will be renewed is understood from the scope of the decision.
Under İYUK Art. 28, the requirements of the decision must be performed without delay and, as a rule, within 30 days at the latest from its notification to the administration. The applicant should follow the notification of the decision to the administration, the measures taken afterwards and any new ground of refusal. Non-implementation of the decision or the establishment of a different measure requires a separate legal assessment.
Source: İYUK, Art. 28.
What should be considered at the appeal stages (istinaf and temyiz)?
The avenue of appeal is determined by the nature of the decision, the procedure applied and the conditions in force. It cannot be assumed that both istinaf (regional appeal) and temyiz (cassation-type appeal) are open for every decision. The date of notification should be recorded; the statement on avenues of appeal in the operative part should be reviewed together with the relevant legislation. In disputes where monetary limits can apply, the current limits and the rules on their application over time must be checked separately. Building the file consistently from day one matters at later stages too; the appeal review is not a stage at which a deficient initial application and deficient preparation of the action will necessarily be remedied.
Source: İYUK, Arts. 20/A, 45 and 46.
How is damage caused by an unlawful refusal claimed?
Annulment of the refusal measure does not mean that compensation is automatically paid to the applicant. Article 12 of İYUK allows a full remedy action to be brought directly because of an administrative measure that violated a right, annulment and full remedy claims to be put forward together, or recourse first to an annulment action. In the last option, the special period rule on the notification of the relevant decision, or, if an appeal was lodged, of the decision given at that stage, must be taken into account. For damage arising from the execution of the measure, the article also takes the date of execution as the basis. There is no single method in every file that makes it mandatory to wait for a final annulment decision.
In a compensation claim, it must be shown which damage arises from which measure. Documented expenses, production and harvest records, income-expense statements and, where applicable, an expert review may be assessed together. Instead of treating all sales revenue not yet realised as damage, the link between the administration’s unlawful conduct and the damage claimed should be explained. The fact that there was in any case no legal possibility of using the land, or a different obstacle, may affect the causation assessment.
If the source of the damage is not the refusal measure but a separate administrative act, the prior-application and time-limit regime in İYUK Art. 13 is addressed separately. A single period or a single prayer for relief should not be assumed for the discussion of the sale or lease right, the objection to an ecrimisil debt and a compensation claim.
Source: İYUK, Arts. 2/1-b, 12 and 13. The explanations on assessing the damage documents together are a legal assessment aimed at the preparation of a concrete action.
Conclusion
In a refusal dispute concerning Treasury agricultural land, the effective legal route begins with first determining the correct sale or lease regime. The refusal letter, the original application and the notification document should be examined together; the period of use, the identity of the user and the legal status of the immovable should be explained with separate evidence. The administration’s discretion does not remove legal review; but proof of use does not, in every case, secure an unconditional right to a contract or a title deed either.
If the filing period is still running, the appropriate application or action should be used within that period. If the period has passed, one should not rely on repeating the same petition; an independent new request, a changed factual or legal situation and, if any, a new statutory application possibility should be investigated. For sales within its scope, 31 December 2026 should also be monitored separately.
The annulment action, eviction and ecrimisil measures, the financial set-off or refund request and the full remedy action for concrete damage should not be reduced to the same measure and period. A workable litigation strategy should combine the correct request, a complete chronology of measures, a parcel-based evidence plan and monitoring of the administration’s obligations after the decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does using Treasury land for many years directly give a right to a title deed?
Long use does not, by itself, produce this result. The entitlement, date, immovable and application conditions of the direct sale or lease regime requested must be met separately.
Does my payment of ecrimisil show that a lease contract was concluded with the administration?
An ecrimisil payment is not by itself a lease contract. As evidence showing the period of use and the counterparty, it may be examined together with other records.
If my purchase request was refused, can I request a lease?
A lease route subject to different conditions may exist. Whether the earlier application included lease and the independence of the new request should be examined; it cannot be assumed that a new filing period is gained merely by changing the heading.
If I object, do I get a fresh 60 days?
Under İYUK Art. 11, an application made within the filing period suspends the period if its conditions are met. After the refusal, the remaining period resumes. The initial application under İYUK Art. 10 and the late-reply provision in the law are different from this.
Is 31 December 2026 the final date for all Treasury leases?
No. The extension in Provisional Art. 1 of Law No. 7579 is for the specified sale regimes and application/payment situations. It cannot be read as a general final application date applicable to all Additional Art. 6 leases.
Does filing an annulment action stop eviction?
Filing an action does not automatically bring about a stay. If there is also an eviction decision, the period, the judicial route and the need for interim protection for that measure must be examined separately.
If I win the annulment action, does the title deed pass to me immediately?
An annulment decision is not, by itself, a transfer of the title deed. The administration is obliged to act in line with the operative part and reasoning; the content of the decision determines the scope of the measure to be carried out.
Can damage caused by an unlawful refusal also be claimed?
If concrete damage, unlawfulness and a causal link exist, a full remedy claim may be assessed separately. An annulment decision does not automatically give rise to compensation. The options and periods in İYUK Art. 12 must be examined according to the specific chain of measures.
How many months do these actions take to conclude?
No completion time valid for every file can be given. Obtaining the case file, the need for an on-site inspection and experts, the court’s workload and the stages of appeal affect the duration. The litigation timetable and the need for urgent interim protection should be planned separately.
Can a building be constructed on agricultural land that has been purchased or leased?
Lease or acquisition of ownership does not replace permits for non-agricultural use and construction. Unauthorised construction and non-agricultural use on agricultural land must be assessed separately.
If I did not open the electronic notification, does the filing period not start?
In electronic notification under Law No. 7201, the date of opening alone is not decisive. The rule that the notification is deemed made at the end of the fifth day following arrival at the electronic address applies. The date should be established from the UETS evidence record. Related explanation.
Can I wait to bring the action because I have requested documents from the administration?
Requesting copies of documents does not automatically suspend the filing period against the main refusal measure. Obtaining the missing records and the filing period should be monitored separately. The request that the court call for the necessary documents can also be made concrete. Related explanation.
Can I request a refund of all the ecrimisil I paid?
There is no general right of refund for all past payments. The special provision to be applied may attach separate results to requests for cancellation, set-off against the sale price and direct refund. The payment period and the date of application matter. Related explanation.
Sources
Date on which the legislation and sources were checked: 20 November 2026. Amending laws have been assessed together with the consolidated provisions.
- Law No. 4706 on Amendments to the Law on the Evaluation of Immovable Property Belonging to the Treasury and to the Value Added Tax Law, Art. 4/12 and Additional Art. 6.
- Law No. 6292 on Supporting the Development of Forest Villagers and on the Evaluation of Areas Removed from Forest Boundaries in the Name of the Treasury and the Sale of Treasury Agricultural Lands, especially Arts. 6, 11 and 12.
- National Real Estate (Millî Emlak) General Communiqués: Communiqués No. 355 and 382; Communiqué No. 387 for direct agricultural lease. Official index of communiqués.
- National Real Estate General Communiqué No. 387. The current text has been assessed together with the amendment made by Communiqué No. 408.
- National Real Estate General Communiqué No. 408, Official Gazette No. 31823 of 28.04.2022; especially Arts. 3, 5 and 6. TÜRMOB archive copy of the Official Gazette text.
- Law No. 7394, Art. 17: amendment of the first paragraph of Additional Art. 6 of Law No. 4706. TBMM text of the law.
- Law No. 7143, Art. 17: creation of Additional Art. 6 of Law No. 4706; sale after ten years of use in accordance with the contract. The current form of the first paragraph must be read together with Law No. 7394.
- Law No. 7579, Provisional Art. 1 and Art. 31; adopted 07.05.2026, Official Gazette: 22.05.2026/33261. Extension of application and payment periods.
- Law No. 2577 on Administrative Procedure (İYUK), especially Arts. 2–15, 20, 20/A, 26–28, 31, 34, 45 and 46.
- Council of State Law No. 2575, Art. 24/1-c: first-instance jurisdiction over regulatory measures applicable nationwide.
- Law No. 7201 on Notification, Arts. 7/a, 11 and 32.
- Law No. 4982 on the Right to Information, Arts. 7 and 9–13.
- Constitutional Court, 17.06.2025, E.2025/137, K.2025/129; Official Gazette 22.09.2025/33025. Rejection of the objection concerning the fifth-day rule.
- Council of State Plenary Session of the Administrative Chambers, 19.10.2020, E.2020/145, K.2020/127. Effect of a repeated application on the period in a personnel-status dispute; the limit of its scope is stated in the text.
- Council of State 4th Chamber, 16.04.2025, E.2025/550, K.2025/2378. Rejection of the request for annulment of the five-kilometre provision of Communiqué No. 382.
- Council of State 4th Chamber, 04.06.2024, E.2023/4845, K.2024/3662. Upholding of the decision dismissing the request for ecrimisil cancellation/refund in the context of Law No. 6292 Art. 11/6.
- Court of Jurisdictional Disputes, 24.11.2025, E.2025/613, K.2025/667. Lease contract concluded under Law No. 3083; not the same dispute as the refusal of an initial lease application.
- PTT, What Is Electronic Notification? Official information on UETS and evidence records.