If the Contractor Goes Bankrupt, What Should the Landowner Do First?
The most dangerous step to take on hearing that the contractor has stopped work is to assume that the contract has ended automatically and to hand the property to another contractor or to make a new title deed transfer. First it must be established whether the company has actually been declared bankrupt, whether it has merely obtained a provisional or final composition moratorium, whether enforcement proceedings (seizures) are pending against it, or whether it is simply experiencing a cash shortage. Each of these has a different legal consequence.
On the same day, the owners should obtain the current title deed records, all encumbrances (mortgages, seizures, injunctions, annotations), registry journal numbers and past transfers; if applicable, verify the case number and decision of the composition/bankruptcy court; and request the building permit, the approved project and the building inspection file from the municipality. If the site has been abandoned, the stage of the work and the ownership of the materials on site should be determined by an independent technical examination; where evidence may be lost, the preservation of evidence under HMK Art. 400 et seq. should be considered. Site safety, open electrical points and pits, structural stability and insurance cover are not merely matters of litigation strategy; they are urgent practical obligations.
Six questions to answer at the first stage
- Does the contractor so far have only financial difficulties, has a composition moratorium been granted, or has bankruptcy been opened?
- In whose name are the land shares and the independent units today; are there sales to third parties or bank mortgages?
- Was the contract executed before a notary in the required official form; are the supplementary protocols and authorization documents valid?
- On what dates did the permit, site handover, commencement of work, the firm deadline set in the contract and any extensions occur?
- Have the level of the partial work, its conformity with the project, its defects and the cost of completion been determined technically?
- What debt and until when does the bank letter of guarantee, mortgage, surety, blocked account or insurance actually secure?
Bankruptcy, Composition, Seizure and Abandoning the Site Are Not the Same Thing
What does the opening of bankruptcy change?
A bankruptcy decision brings into play the relationship of the bankrupt's seizable assets and rights with the bankruptcy estate, the limitation of the power to dispose of assets, and the collective liquidation for creditors (İİK Art. 184, 191 et seq.). The shares registered in the contractor's name, the receivables it has earned and its dealings with third parties are each examined separately. The opening of bankruptcy does not give the landowner a right to take back every property directly. Standing to be a party on behalf of the bankruptcy estate and authority to pursue the case are also important; the representation regime is not the same in ordinary and summary liquidation.
Special consequences must be examined under İİK Art. 198, such as the conversion of non-monetary claims into money claims and the bankruptcy administration's ability to undertake performance in kind. This provision cannot be read to mean that every construction contract is automatically converted into cash or that the owners' claims for return of title deeds can never be heard. The source of the claim, its in rem nature and the concrete contractual relationship must be determined.
What does a composition moratorium change?
Composition (konkordato) is a judicial process in which the debtor seeks to restructure its debts; it is not the same as bankruptcy. The provisional/final moratorium decisions under İİK Art. 285 et seq. have consequences in particular for the prohibition on enforcement (Art. 294), the debtor's dispositions (Art. 297) and contracts that are important for the continuation of the business (Art. 296). A composition application alone does not mean that the construction contract can be terminated in every case, or that it can never be terminated.
İİK Art. 296 places limits, for contracts important to the continuation of the business, on provisions that provide for termination or acceleration merely because of a composition application. By contrast, genuine and separate breaches of contract before or after the composition, the commissioner's stance, the importance of the contract for the project and the protection requested are assessed together. An owner cannot, on his or her own, conclude that "composition has been announced, so all the title deeds have come back."
Abandoning the site and the arrival of seizures
The contractor's withdrawing its workers, failing to pay social security (SGK)/supplier debts or negotiating with banks is not a bankruptcy decision. These facts may, however, be evidence of default, of it having become clear that the work cannot be completed on time, of interim legal protection and of the security in the contract. Because enforcement proceedings, seizure, precautionary seizure and mortgage are not in the same rank and do not belong to the same right holder, the current title deed extract is decisive.
Once bankruptcy is opened, how are performance of the contract and the party to the case determined?
A bankruptcy decision is not a single act of termination that automatically ends the contractor's duty of performance in every case. Under İİK Art. 198, the value in the bankruptcy estate of non-monetary claims and whether the bankruptcy administration will continue with a contract imposing reciprocal obligations are examined. In particular, the objective feasibility of completing the construction, the financial resources of the estate, the statements and decisions of the bankruptcy administration, the counter-performance of the employer (landowner) and the rights acquired by that date must be assessed together.
That the bankruptcy administration does not undertake performance of the contract does not mean that all construction work done earlier is without value. The amount of the work completed, the method by which the contract ended and, if any, the economic benefit the work provides to the landowner affect the parties' liquidation claims. In the 23rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay)'s decision of 24.10.2018, E.2016/2735, K.2018/4918, the estate's decision not to continue the work and the price of the completed work were together made the subject of the dispute; the existence of the decision does not show that the same liquidation result will emerge in every file.
In cases filed before bankruptcy, the suspension and resumption regime of İİK Art. 194 is examined in terms of whether the dispute concerns the bankruptcy estate and whether the case relates to a right in rem or to a monetary claim to be registered with the estate. The representation of the estate in ordinary liquidation and the position of the bankruptcy office in summary liquidation are not the same. In the Court of Cassation 23rd Civil Chamber, 07.03.2018, E.2015/9483, K.2018/2080, the necessity of completing the joinder of the bankruptcy administration as a party after the contractor's bankruptcy was emphasized.
Why must rights before and after the bankruptcy decision be distinguished?
A rent, delay or compensation claim of the owner that arose and fell due before bankruptcy was opened, and a debt arising after bankruptcy from a contract the bankruptcy estate itself undertook, may not be assessed in the same rank and by the same procedure. A bankruptcy claim, an estate debt, a claim secured by pledge and a restitution claim based on ownership must be classified not merely by their labels but by their true legal cause and date of origin. No claim should be asserted to be an estate debt with priority automatically.
Why Does a Flat-for-Land Construction Contract Carry Special Risk?
A flat-for-land (arsa payı karşılığı) construction contract is a mixed-type contract that includes both the contractor's obligation to produce the work and the owner's obligation, under certain conditions, to transfer land shares or independent units. The landowner often transfers not money but the economic value of his or her property as the consideration. The contractor's financing difficulties therefore cause not only delay in delivery; they also affect the owners' title security, the financing mortgage and relations with third parties.
As a rule, the contractor must complete and deliver the work stipulated in the contract, and the consideration it has earned must be determined. However, in some contracts title deed transfer was made to the contractor at the beginning or in stages. Up-front title transfer can create financing for the construction but increases the risk of recovery. If the contractor transfers the deed to a third party or mortgages it to a bank, the termination claim no longer remains only between the owner and the contractor.
The general contract, default and return of title deeds aspects of this subject are examined separately in our firm's articles Construction Contracts Guide and Termination of Flat-for-Land Construction and Return of Title Deeds. The distinctive subject of this guide is how title deed–estate–security–completion decisions are managed together after payment difficulties arise. For the formation of the contract, title deed transfer and delivery stages, see our guide Flat-for-Land (Kat Karşılığı) Construction Contract, and for contract issues specific to risky-structure projects, our article Flat-for-Land Construction Contract in Urban Transformation.
What If the Title Deeds Are Still in the Landowner's Name?
If the shares have not yet been transferred to the contractor, the risk relating to the property itself differs from that for a property transferred at the outset. Even so, "there is no risk at all" cannot be said without examining the contract annotations, the contractor's personal rights, the powers of attorney given for construction, the consideration for the work the contractor has performed and the commitments made to third parties. The bankruptcy estate may assert the contractor's rights arising from the existing contract; the owner, too, may assess his or her own unperformed obligations and defenses.
Before the owners reach an agreement with a new contractor, it must be determined whether the old contract has been properly terminated, what price for the work the previous contractor may have earned, the transfer of the permit and building inspection, and who owns the site materials. Otherwise the second contract, instead of removing the risks arising from the first, may create a dispute with two separate creditors.
If the Title Deeds Were Transferred to the Contractor, How Are They Recovered?
For shares registered in the contractor's name, merely sending a notice generally does not change the registry. It must be shown under which contract and in return for which stage the transferred share was given, whether the contractor earned it, and for what reason the contract ended. In an appropriate action, termination of the contract, cancellation of the title deed and re-registration, and, where necessary, claims for price or damages may be asserted together or in a subsidiary form suited to the conditions.
However, where the contractor is bankrupt, the bankruptcy administration's/office's authority to pursue the case, the relationship with the estate, claims already accepted for registration and the legal nature of the claim in rem must be assessed separately. The landowner's claim for return of the title deed should not be treated merely as an "unpaid monetary claim" with all the consequences of a judgment equated.
2024 Court of Cassation decision: Registering a money claim with the estate does not mean rejecting the title deed claim
Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, 27.03.2024, E.2024/689, K.2024/755. In a file in which the claimant landowner had transferred several land shares and was awaiting flats in return, a claim of TRY 30,000 had been registered with the bankruptcy estate. On the basis of this registration, the court had ruled that there was no need to rule in the case. The Court of Cassation found that the scope of the application to the estate had not been investigated and that whether the claim for cancellation and re-registration of the title deed was within the same application, and the bankruptcy administration's stance on it, had not been determined; it set aside its earlier affirmation and reversed the local court's judgment.
Limit of the decision: With this judgment the Court of Cassation did not rule that the landowner will definitely recover the title deed; it required the incomplete investigation to be completed. This precedent therefore shows that the application made to the bankruptcy estate with the petition must be matched claim by claim.
Flats Sold to Third Parties and Bank Mortgages: The 2025 Decision of Unification of Case Law
The Court of Cassation Grand General Assembly for Unification of Case Law, 16.05.2025, E.2024/1, K.2025/2, was published in the Official Gazette (Resmî Gazete) of 18.07.2025. According to the decision, where shares or independent units transferred to the contractor were sold to or mortgaged in favour of third parties and the contract is later found invalid or terminated retroactively, the third party's defense that it acquired a right in rem in good faith, relying on the land registry, must be heard. A good-faith ownership or mortgage right whose conditions are met may be protected. If it is shown in the concrete case that the third party was not in good faith, a different result may follow.
This decision rejects the automatic result that "because the contractor did not finish the construction, the third party's title deed is necessarily cancelled." Conversely, it does not mean that every title deed sale or mortgage will necessarily be protected. The third party's date of acquisition, the appearance in the registry, whether it knew of the project and the state of construction, the network of relations and other evidence that may show bad faith are assessed. The decision itself does not remove the bankruptcy and composition provisions; the bankruptcy estate and the relationship in rem are separate legal dimensions.
By what evidence is the third party's good faith contested?
The state of knowledge of the buyer or mortgage creditor on the date the property was acquired is important. Land registry transaction records, annotations, the genuineness of the sale price, payments, contract and advertisement documents, site images, notary notices, closeness between the persons concerned, the credit file and the appraisal report must each be examined for relevance, date and lawful acquisition. However, the mere fact that the buyer acquired the deed from the contractor or that the construction later stopped does not by itself prove bad faith. For the third party's good faith and the title deed cancellation action, see our article Can a Title Deed Obtained from a Contractor Be Cancelled?.
Third parties who buy a flat from the contractor and the landowner are not in the same legal position
The legal basis of an owner who transferred title to the contractor and that of a consumer or investor who bought an independent unit from the contractor are not always the same. While the landowner can rely on the termination of the contract and on his or her earlier ownership, the buyer may face issues of the promise-to-sell contract made with the contractor, registration, reliance on the land registry, delivery and registration of a claim with the bankruptcy estate. Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, 25.01.2023, E.2022/3194, K.2023/257, is one of the concrete decisions showing the importance of separating a claim in rem after bankruptcy from a claim converted into a money claim against the estate. The registration and compensation routes of a person who bought a flat from the contractor but did not get the title deed are explained in our article What to Do If the Contractor Does Not Hand Over the Title Deed?.
These decisions should be read together with the unification decision of 16.05.2025, with the different facts and procedural issues of the decisions explained. The earlier decision discusses a buyer's contractual position against bankruptcy; the unification decision discusses whether the acquisition of a right in rem by a person who took over after a flat-for-land contract, relying on the registry, can be protected. A mandatory result cannot be drawn from one to the other in all files.
What Can Owners Do If There Is a Bank Mortgage?
Was the mortgage established for the owner's own debt, for the contractor's financing, or for a third party's debt? Did the owner consent to the mortgage, and what authority did the representative exercise? The ceiling, rank, scope of the claim, the secured credit, release conditions and the date the mortgage was established must be determined together. A bankruptcy or composition decision alone does not erase the mortgage from the land registry.
The nature of the mortgage established by the bank, the good-faith defense and the 2025 unification decision are assessed together. Where there is a risk of forced enforcement against a mortgaged property, suing only the contractor may not be enough. The target property, the current mortgagee, the necessary joinder of parties, an action suited to the substantive right and interim protection must be planned separately.
Is "there is a bank letter of guarantee" always enough?
The beneficiary, addressee, amount of the guarantee, the breach of which obligation will trigger payment, its final/provisional nature, the conditions for a demand and its last validity date of the bank letter of guarantee must be checked. Payment conditions vary according to the type and text of the document. If the term of the guarantee expires before the actual date of completion of the construction, that security may be practically ineffective. One should not proceed on the assumption that there is an on-first-demand payment clause or a bank credit guarantee; the original document and its amendments must be read.
Can the Contract Be Terminated During the Composition Process?
İİK Art. 296 contains protective provisions especially for contracts of importance to the composition project. In this scope, provisions that the contract will be terminated automatically merely because of a composition request cannot be enforced in every case. But the contractor's never starting the work, its breach of the delivery obligation in the contract, its failure to obtain the necessary permit or its inability to continue the construction may rest on different legal grounds, independently of this.
For this reason, first the provisional/final moratorium dates, commissioner reports, the debtor company's operating plan and the place of the concrete construction in the project in the composition file must be determined. The addressee of the notice and termination declaration and the capacity of the authorized representative must also be verified. Because of the general prohibition on enforcement, collectibility and the conditions of a request to terminate the contract are not the same.
Practical example: The day the contractor applies for composition may not alone be regarded as a ground for termination. By contrast, if it is shown with technical evidence that on a site that had been closed for months before the moratorium the work objectively cannot be completed, TBK Art. 473 or the default provisions may be separately argued. Which applies depends on the characteristics of the project and the contract.
A composition application and an independent ground of default must not be confused
İİK Art. 296/1 prevents the application of clauses providing for termination of the contract, acceleration of the debt or ending of the contract merely on the ground of applying for composition, in contracts important for the continuation of the debtor's business. The reciprocal obligations of contracts that continue during the moratorium are also performed within the scope of the same provision. This protection does not render all of the contractor's breaches of contract outside composition legally ineffective. The date the site was abandoned, permit delay, departure from the work schedule, notice and additional period are each separate factual grounds; it must be shown whether they are independent and genuinely applicable in a termination or withdrawal claim.
Under İİK Art. 296/2, by contrast, the composition debtor's termination of an excessively burdensome continuing obligation is a different route that can arise with the commissioner's favourable opinion and the court's permission; it cannot be confused with the owners' unilateral right of termination. Whether the concrete construction contract falls within the scope of these provisions must also be determined separately.
In the proceedings subject to the decision of the Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, 18.09.2023, E.2022/2362, K.2023/2804, there are claims and defenses of the parties based on the prohibition on termination on account of composition. A legal assertion appearing only in a party's statement in the decision should not be presented as a definitive principle adopted directly by the Chamber. For application to a particular contract, the final reasoning and judgment of the decision are what matter.
Which Claims Can Be Notified to the Bankruptcy Estate?
Rent loss, late-delivery penalty, completion expenses, the price of return or liquidation of the work and other compensation must be classified one by one according to their legal basis, period and evidence. It is possible to gather all the items in a single application; but for each of them the date the claim arose, its maturity, security, rank and calculation method must be explained separately. Consistency must be established between the subject of an action opened with notification to the estate and the title deed claim.
The time limits in the bankruptcy announcement and claim registration process depend on the form of liquidation and the specific announcements. A generalization such as "every action must be brought within X days at the latest from the announcement of bankruptcy" must not be made; the service and announcement records of the bankruptcy file must be checked. If it is asserted that a direct right in rem exists over the property, it must also be investigated separately whether the claim is merely monetary in nature.
Bankruptcy claim registration, the ranking schedule and time limits: Which step must an owner not miss?
The bankruptcy announcement, the call to register claims and the announcement of the ranking schedule are separate starting events. In ordinary liquidation, under İİK Art. 219, a call is made for creditors and persons claiming a right of restitution, as a rule for one month from the last announcement. The form of liquidation, the text of the announcement, the possibility of being abroad and the concrete file actions must be checked. If notification is not made in time, the claim does not entirely disappear on its own: İİK Art. 236 applies separately in respect of late notification, costs, being unable to take part in a distribution already decided, and review of the supplementary ranking schedule.
Under İİK Art. 234 the ranking schedule is announced. Under İİK Art. 235, an action to challenge the ranking schedule is, as a rule, subject to 15 days from the announcement; the special provision on service in Art. 223 is reserved. An objection directed at the substance, amount and rank of the claim differs from a complaint against the procedure of the bankruptcy administration's act. Moreover, registration of a money claim and asserting ownership or another right in rem over the property must not be treated as the same type of application. The calculation of time limits must be made by a lawyer on a file basis, together with the last announcement/service, the applicant's capacity and holidays.
| Step or application | General legal basis | Time and control criterion | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notification of claims and restitution in ordinary liquidation | İİK Art. 219 | Starting from the last announcement, as a rule 1 month; the concrete announcement and exceptions are examined | Late registration, costs and participation in distribution |
| Late notification of a claim | İİK Art. 236 | Until the bankruptcy is closed; opportunities and limits examined separately | Inability to take part in an already decided distribution |
| Announcement and service of the ranking schedule | İİK Art. 223, 234 | Announcement date and the conditions for benefiting from service are recorded separately | Loss of rights through a wrong starting point |
| Action challenging the ranking schedule | İİK Art. 235 | As a rule 15 days; Art. 223 special provision reserved | Failure to raise a registration/acceptance or rank claim in time |
| Title deed and right in rem claim in the bankruptcy estate | İİK Art. 184, 198, 206; TMK | Separate action and party analysis according to the nature of the claim | Registering a money claim and leaving the title deed claim unpursued |
| Continuing a case filed before bankruptcy | İİK Art. 194, 226 | Type of action, joinder of parties and liquidation procedure are examined | Continuing proceedings against a party without standing |
Does registering a money claim satisfy the claim for cancellation and re-registration of the title deed?
No; it does not satisfy it automatically. The landowner's notifying the estate of a monetary claim for rent or for the price paid does not make unnecessary the legal examination of the separate claim he or she asserts concerning the title deed of the property transferred to the contractor. In the decision Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, 27.03.2024, E.2024/689, K.2024/755, reaching the conclusion that the case had become moot as to the claim for cancellation and re-registration of the title deed on the basis of a TRY 30,000 money claim registered with the estate was regarded as incomplete examination. The Chamber set aside the affirmation and reversed the first-instance decision on the ground that the content of the application submitted to the estate and the extent to which the claim in rem was addressed must be investigated.
The result is not that every owner recovers the title deed: First it must be investigated on which property, which right, which person and which bankruptcy actions the title deed claim rests; the limited binding effect of the decision's reversal aspect must be taken into account. If the title has passed to a third party or a mortgage has been created, the good-faith possibility protected by the 2025 unification decision is also considered.
Suspicious transfers before bankruptcy and the owner's title deed claim are different legal routes
If before bankruptcy the contractor transferred assets to related companies or made transfers at unusual prices, this may, where the conditions exist, be examined under İİK Art. 277 et seq. on the annulment of dispositions. But the relative-effect annulment of dispositions pursued for the benefit of the bankruptcy estate or creditors must not be confused with the determination of the right in rem the landowner asserts to be his or her own and the claim for title deed cancellation and re-registration. The two routes are not asserted together automatically without assessing the authority to pursue and the interest to sue in bankruptcy liquidation.
Completion of the Work or Withdrawal from the Contract: Which Is More Suitable?
Performance in kind and additional period
If the contractor is still able to ensure completion of the work, default, additional period, performance and delay damages may be examined within the framework of TBK Art. 117, 123–125. The creditor's demanding performance in kind and withdrawing from the contract and claiming restitution are not the same result. Bankruptcy and composition restrictions are also taken into account separately.
Withdrawal before delivery under TBK Art. 473
Under TBK Art. 473/1, if the contractor does not start the work on time, delays it contrary to what was agreed, or it becomes clear that it cannot finish on time, for reasons not attributable to the employer, withdrawal without waiting for the delivery date may arise. For this route to be used, which work must be completed when and who caused the delay is made concrete.
Defects, having another contractor complete the work, and costs
TBK Art. 473/2 regulates, where it is clearly seen that the work will be produced defectively/contrary to the contract, granting time for correction and, if the conditions exist, the possibility of having the work done by a third party. Performance at the other party's expense (nama ifa) under TBK Art. 113 is also assessed according to the nature of the concrete obligation. These provisions do not mean that the owners may in every case give the whole site to another contractor without a court decision. First the security of rights and evidence must be ensured, and the scope of work to be given to the new contractor must be calculated.
Retroactive or prospective effect of termination
The decision of the Court of Cassation Grand General Assembly for Unification of Case Law of 25.01.1984, E.1983/3, K.1984/1, allows a discussion of prospective effect according to the specific features in flat-for-land construction contracts terminated by the contractor's culpable default. This decision does not set an automatic 90% completion threshold. The economic value of the work, its conformity with the project, its usability, the parties' conduct and the result of termination must be examined together. The new 2025 unification decision applies separately, in particular with respect to the rights in rem of third parties.
How Is the Completion Percentage of Construction Proven?
There is a difference between the percentage of rough concrete level alone and a finished, legally deliverable independent unit. The approved permit, project, building inspection records, work actually done, missing and defective work, structural safety, common areas, electricity–water infrastructure and the possibility of obtaining an occupancy permit must be assessed. An expert report must distinguish the quantity of work as of the inspection date from conformity with the obligations provided in the contract.
The expert should not reduce the value of the existing work and the cost of completion to a single figure. Correction of defective parts of completed work, additional work required by the municipality, a subsequently altered project and additional work requested by the owners are calculated separately. If work is carried out on the construction after the preservation of evidence, it must be shown by which photographs, measurements and records the former state was recorded.
A five-stage model applicable for having the project completed by a new contractor
First stage — legal authority: Whether the old contract has ended, the bankruptcy administration's choice whether to continue the contract, any title deed dispute, land shares and powers of representation are tied to separate records and decisions. No new transfer commitment is given before conflicting rights are resolved.
Second stage — technical limit: Existing work, defective and unauthorized work, structural safety, nonconformity with the project, and the materials and equipment on site are determined, where necessary, by preservation of evidence under HMK Art. 400. Equipment that is the old contractor's property or over which the bankruptcy estate asserts a claim cannot be freely used by the owners merely because it is on the site.
Third stage — financing: The price of the remaining work, ground improvement, mandatory permit/project amendments, labour and safety costs, legal expenses and possible delay are budgeted as separate items by an independent technical expert. The budget is not reduced to a unit square-metre cost alone.
Fourth stage — new contract: The responsibility the new contractor will and will not assume from previous work, the delivery schedule, security, the stage of title deed transfer, insurance and the technical acceptance of the work are expressly determined in the contract. Owner decision and offer processes under Law No. 6306 are separated from the intention to be a party to the contract.
Fifth stage — implementing the results: Dated implementation officers are designated for the necessary permit and building inspection procedures, site responsibility, social security (SGK) and subcontractor records, occupancy permit, condominium ownership and, where applicable, deed/pledge cancellations. Signing a decision or a contract does not show that the work is finished.
When Can Owners Sign a Contract with a New Contractor?
Finding a new contractor may be economically urgent; however, a new contract made before the old contract, the title deeds and the bankruptcy process are completed may create conflicting rights over the same land. The type and effect of the old contract's termination, ownership of the title deeds, mortgages/seizures, the contractor's claim arising from completed work, and permit and building inspection responsibility must be determined. If the contract is being transferred to the new contractor, it must be borne in mind that this is not the same as a change of shareholders or a change of subcontractor of the previous contractor.
For the work to be given to the new contractor, the technical completion budget, stage programme, firm delivery date, security, rent payment, material liability, which party undertakes which of the existing defects and the stages of title deed transfer must be rewritten. Whether each owner is a party to the new contract must be determined taking into account the distinction between the majority decision under Law No. 6306 and an individual contractual obligation.
How Are the Owners' Decision and Share Sale Affected Under Law No. 6306?
In projects within the scope of a risky structure or risky area, the owners' simple majority decision by land share ratio, the notification and sale of the shares of non-participating owners, agreement with a new contractor and representation are different legal acts. Obtaining a simple majority decision does not mean that everyone who did not take part automatically becomes liable for all the obligations of the same private-law contract.
The amendments of 4 February 2026 to the Implementing Regulation and the current procedures for call, decision, offer, valuation and sale under Art. 6 of Law No. 6306 must be examined according to the text applicable on the date of the event. The documents of termination of the contract with the existing contractor, the meeting on the new decision and the notification to non-participating owners must be kept. In calculating time limits, which act was served and which legal remedy was used must be shown separately. For detailed procedure, see our article Objection to the Sale of Land Shares in Urban Transformation.
How Are Securities Really Enforced?
| Security | What to check | Common risk |
|---|---|---|
| Bank letter of guarantee | Addressee, condition, term, amount, payment demand | Term expired or event outside scope |
| Mortgage in favour of the owner | Rank, amount, which debt it secures, release | Weak security due to prior mortgages |
| Personal surety | Written form, maximum amount, date, exceptions to spousal consent | Defect of form and difficulty of collection |
| Cash blocked or escrow account | Authority to block, account holder, payment condition | Unconditional release of the account |
| Insurance | Subject of the policy, beneficiary, cover limit, deductibles | Not covering bankruptcy/completion risk |
| Staged transfer of the title deed | Construction stage, technical approval, transfer ratio | Divergence between actual progress and title deed transfer |
No security alone removes all risks. A bank letter of guarantee is not an automatic equivalent of title deed transfer security, insurance of a cash completion guarantee, or surety of a security in rem. Duplication must not arise among securities in terms of collection, conversion of the security into money and set-off of payments.
How Is Compensation and Loss Calculated After Bankruptcy?
The calculation of compensation depends on the result with which the contract ended. Delay damage, rent loss, the contractual penalty, the price of missing work, the cost of repairing defects, temporary accommodation expense, financing difference and the completion price with the new contractor are not a single item. For each type of loss, the breach, proof, causation, fault and contractual exceptions are examined. Different claims must not compensate the same economic loss twice.
Example calculation check: First the contractor's work done and conforming to the contract is calculated separately; then the missing part that must be completed, defect corrections, mandatory new work and additional work preferred by the owners are calculated separately. If any, the title deed values transferred to the old contractor, guarantees collected from the bank, rent payments made and the insurance amount received are set off according to their proper legal nature. This is not an automatic amount formula but a document-based liquidation principle and a check against double recovery.
Why does collection of a claim differ in bankruptcy and composition?
A court's accepting a claim in favour of the landowner does not mean that the whole of the same amount will immediately be collected. Bankruptcy liquidation, the ranking schedule, the distinctions between pledge and estate claims; and in composition the confirmation decision and payment plan may affect the result. For this reason being in the right, the legal nature of the claim and actual collectibility should be assessed in separate columns.
In Which Court Are Actions Filed, and Is Mediation Required?
Cancellation and re-registration of the title deed, termination of the contract, claim/compensation, cancellation of the mortgage, a registration or ranking-schedule dispute concerning the bankruptcy estate are distinct types of legal protection. Under the single heading "the contractor went bankrupt," the competent court is not the same for all of them. Under HMK Art. 12 the exclusive jurisdiction in actions relating to immovable property itself; depending on the parties' capacity, commercial, consumer or general court jurisdiction; and, in terms of bankruptcy and composition, the special jurisdiction and competence rules of enforcement and bankruptcy law must be assessed.
In commercial or consumer monetary claims there is the possibility of mandatory mediation as a condition of suit; the same result cannot be drawn mechanically for every action relating to a title deed or every application directed at the bankruptcy estate. In particular, a petition must not be drawn up without determining the nature of the claim, the claims filed together and the special route of action in the bankruptcy process. If bankruptcy is opened during the proceedings, whether the joinder of parties and the authority to pursue the case have changed must also be examined.
Interim injunction and interim protection
If there is a risk of transfer of the property to a third party, creation of a mortgage or loss of evidence on the site, the interim injunction under HMK Art. 389 et seq., preservation of evidence under HMK Art. 400 et seq. and other suitable protection routes are considered. The conditions of each, in terms of prima facie proof, proportionality, security and the rights of third parties, are separate. That an interim injunction has been requested does not mean that a prohibition is automatically entered in the land registry; the court decision and registry practice must be verified. The intersection of these requests with the enforcement/injunction regime of bankruptcy and composition is also checked separately.
How are site debts, insurance and collection of securities coordinated?
That the contractor owes debts to workers, subcontractors, suppliers, the tax authority or SGK does not mean that these debts are automatically the personal debt of all the landowners. On the other hand, they may create concrete obstacles for the stopping of the work, permit or occupancy-permit procedures, ownership of site materials, the contractor's progress payment and the new contractor's starting work. The old contract, building inspection records, payroll, insurance policy, site handover record and the real counterparty of the debts must be compared.
In a bank letter of guarantee, the date by which and the document with which the notice required for payment will be given; in a mortgage, the creditor's rank and the limit of the security; in surety, the form and, if any, spousal consent; in insurance, the capacity of the insured and the beneficiary are determined. That a security exists on paper differs from its actually being collectible. A security must not be allowed to lapse by limitation in reliance merely on the existence of the claim.
After the decision, who will complete what?
Finality of the judgment, enforceability where necessary, the transaction at the land registry office, the request for cancellation of the mortgage, the bankruptcy administration's ranking schedule and distribution processes, adaptation of the municipal permit and handover of the new site are followed as separate work items. Which result depends on which administrative or judicial decision, and which party will act after the decision, is determined file by file. In this way the practical gap between acquiring the right and actual collection and restarting construction is closed.
Decision Matrix: Which Route Is Investigated in Which Situation?
| Concrete situation | First legal examination | Assumption that is not enough alone |
|---|---|---|
| Construction stopped, no bankruptcy decision | Default, TBK 473, preservation of evidence | "Work paused = bankruptcy" |
| Provisional composition moratorium exists | İİK 294, 296, 297; commissioner and contract | "Composition = automatic termination" |
| Contractor's bankruptcy opened | Bankruptcy estate, registration, representation, İİK 198 | "All title deeds come back" |
| Title deed is with the contractor | Entitlement to progress payment, outcome of the contract, title deed action | "A notice wipes out the title deed" |
| Title deed is with a third party | TMK 1023, 2025 unification decision, moment of acquisition | "The third party is definitely in bad faith" |
| There is a bank mortgage | Mortgage document, credit, rank and beneficiary | "Termination erases the mortgage" |
| Site partly completed | Expert, defect, cost, liquidation | "The percentage alone decides the judgment" |
| New contractor to be selected | Status of the old contract and Law No. 6306 processes | "A new signature ends the old one" |
45-Item Action and Evidence Checklist for the Landowner
- Obtain the contractor company's current trade registry, representation and shareholder records.
- Verify the actual bankruptcy or composition decision against the court file.
- Record separately the provisional/final moratorium and the date bankruptcy was opened.
- Identify the capacity of the bankruptcy administration, bankruptcy office or composition commissioner.
- Preserve the complete official copy of the first flat-for-land construction contract.
- Examine together the supplementary protocols, delivery changes and powers of attorney.
- Compare the first and current title deed records of the land.
- Obtain dated encumbrance, seizure and mortgage extracts.
- Extract the registry journal and acquisition dates of transfers to third parties.
- Check the scope of annotations and whether they have ended.
- Obtain the building permit, revised project and municipal letters.
- Keep the building inspection firm's records and progress payments.
- Keep a record of the dates of site handover, commencement of work and site delivery.
- Draw up the firm delivery date, additional periods and the rent payment schedule.
- Determine the current safety and hazard condition of the site.
- If necessary, plan technical preservation of evidence under HMK Art. 400.
- Measure separately the rough, fine and infrastructure levels of the construction.
- Separate defective work and work contrary to the permit.
- Calculate separately the price of the existing work and the remaining completion cost.
- Check the originals and terms of bank letters of guarantee.
- Verify the claim and rank details of bank mortgages.
- Examine the validity of the surety and guarantee conditions.
- Show blocked accounts, insurance and cash securities in a single list.
- Preserve notary notices and records of dispatch and service.
- Record the notifications made to the composition commissioner.
- Classify separately each claim notified to the bankruptcy estate and its basis.
- Check how the title deed or mortgage claim was handled in the bankruptcy estate.
- Tie the ranking schedule and announcement dates to the calendar.
- Determine claims and parties by property in the necessary action.
- In the event of a new sale or mortgage threat, examine the conditions for interim protection.
- Collect lawfully the evidence on the third party's good faith.
- Clarify the existing contractual relationship before agreeing with the new contractor.
- Verify the new owner decision and notification process under Law No. 6306.
- Free rent, delay, security and compensation payments from duplication.
- Build a responsibility calendar for post-decision title deed, site, permit and collection implementation.
- Confirm in writing the last date of the bankruptcy announcement and the ordinary/summary liquidation distinction.
- Enter the İİK Art. 219 claim-registration call and the one-month period in the calendar.
- Check separately the ranking schedule announcement and the possibility of special service.
- Calculate on a file basis the as-a-rule 15-day objection period under İİK Art. 235.
- In the event of late notification of a claim, examine İİK Art. 236 and distribution results.
- Record title deed, restitution, monetary claim and mortgage claims on separate legal claim sheets.
- Document the bankruptcy administration's will to continue or not continue the contract and its power of representation.
- Separate the Art. 296 composition protection from default grounds independent of composition.
- Prepare the record of the old work's fault and completion responsibility for the new contractor.
- Assign dated collection/cancellation notices for the letter of guarantee, mortgage and insurance to those responsible.
Conclusion
When the contractor goes bankrupt, the owners' rights are not lost automatically; but neither do the title deeds and unpaid compensation come back automatically. The priority is to verify the official bankruptcy/composition status, untangle the chain of title deeds and mortgages, record the level of construction technically and direct the right claim to the right counterparty. Because of the 2025 unification decision, the good faith of third parties must be examined independently. Registration of a claim with the bankruptcy estate and a claim for cancellation of the title deed must not be confused; before a new contractor contract, the legal limits of the old relationship and of the liquidation must be set out.
Frequently Asked Questions
If the contractor goes bankrupt, will the landowner definitely get the title deed back?
No. In whose name the title deed is, on what right it was transferred, with what legal result the contract ended, and whether there are rights of third parties are each examined separately.
If the contractor declares composition, is the contract automatically cancelled?
No. A composition application and the effects of the moratorium are assessed under İİK Art. 294, 296 and 297. Genuine breaches of contract and the conditions for termination are investigated separately.
What can be done if the contractor abandons the site without going bankrupt?
Default, TBK Art. 473/1, preservation of evidence, securities and routes of termination may come into play. The absence of a bankruptcy decision does not wholly prevent legal applications.
Can an agreement be made immediately with another contractor if the construction is left unfinished?
It is not safe in every case. If the legal status of the old contract, the title deeds, the existing work and the Law No. 6306 decision processes are not examined, a new commitment may lead to conflicting rights.
What happens if the land shares given to the contractor have been sold to a third party?
Under the Decision of Unification of Case Law of 16.05.2025, the third party's defense of reliance on the land registry and good faith is heard. Bad faith can be asserted with concrete evidence.
Is the bank mortgage erased when the contract is terminated?
It is not erased automatically. The mortgage document, the registry, the date of acquisition, the right holder and the third party's good faith are examined.
Does notifying a claim to the bankruptcy estate replace the title deed action?
Not always. In its decision of 27.03.2024, the Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber emphasized that the scope of a monetary claim registration and of a claim for cancellation and re-registration of the title deed must be investigated separately.
Does the contractor's bankruptcy extinguish the rent assistance claim?
The existence of a claim differs from the likelihood of collection. The legal basis and period of rent and delay payments, the bankruptcy estate and any securities are assessed together.
If 90 percent of the construction is finished, is withdrawal impossible?
By law there is no single percentage threshold applied to every case. Conformity to performance, usability, completion and the features of the concrete case are examined.
In which court is an action filed if the contractor is bankrupt?
Jurisdiction and competence vary according to whether the claim relates to the title deed, the contract, the bankruptcy estate or the ranking schedule. There is no single general court answer.
Is a person who bought a flat from the contractor also affected by these cases?
Yes, in particular title-conferring transactions, reliance on the registry and the contractor's bankruptcy may be relevant. The buyer's capacity as consumer or third party, contract, and the date of registration and acquisition must be examined separately.
Can the owners directly sell the shares of non-signing co-owners?
No. Under Law No. 6306, the simple majority, meeting, offer, valuation and sale procedures are subject to statutory conditions. A decision alone is not a direct forced sale.
How many days are there to register a claim with the bankruptcy estate?
In ordinary liquidation, under İİK Art. 219, a call to notify is, as a rule, made for one month from the last announcement. Late notification is separately regulated in İİK Art. 236; the announcement, the form of liquidation and the risks of loss of rights must be examined in the concrete file.
Within how many days is an objection to the ranking schedule made?
Under İİK Art. 235, an action must as a rule be filed within 15 days from the date of announcement; the special service provision of İİK Art. 223 is reserved. The procedure for complaint and for registration–acceptance claims is not the same.
If a contractor under composition stops the work for months, can the contract be terminated?
A composition application alone is not in every case a ground for termination. However, the termination consequences of provable breaches of contract independent of composition are assessed separately, in terms of İİK Art. 296, the contract and the applicable general provisions.
If the bankruptcy estate registers my rent claim, will it also return my title deed?
No. Acceptance of a money claim and a claim for cancellation and re-registration of the title deed may require different legal assessments. The decision of the Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber of 27.03.2024 is a reversal example that regards investigation of this distinction as mandatory.
When the contractor goes bankrupt, what is the first condition for having the construction completed by a new contractor?
The legal status of the old contract and the title deed rights must be clarified. Then the technical preservation of evidence, the budget for the remaining work, security, the owners' decision and the validity of the new contract are examined together.
Sources
Legislation
- Law No. 6098, Turkish Code of Obligations, in particular Art. 97, 112–113, 117, 123–125, 146–147, 470–484.
- Law No. 2004, Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, in particular Art. 184, 191, 194, 198, 206, 219, 223, 234–236, 285–308 and 296.
- Law No. 4721, Turkish Civil Code, in particular Art. 2–3, 705, 1009, 1023–1024.
- Law No. 6100, Code of Civil Procedure, in particular Art. 12, 389–405.
- Law No. 6306, in particular Art. 6 and Implementing Regulation Art. 15/A (the version applicable on the date of the event).
Case law
- Court of Cassation 23rd Civil Chamber, 24.10.2018, E.2016/2735, K.2018/4918. The bankruptcy estate's decision not to continue the contract and liquidation of the price of the work. Decision text (De Jure)
- Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, 25.01.2023, E.2022/3194, K.2023/257. The position, after bankruptcy, of a third party who bought an independent unit from the contractor as to monetary/in rem claims. Decision text (De Jure)
- Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, 18.09.2023, E.2022/2362, K.2023/2804. A dispute in which composition and termination claims were at issue; the parties' assertions must not be confused with the judgment. Decision text (De Jure)
- Court of Cassation Grand General Assembly for Unification of Case Law, 16.05.2025, E.2024/1, K.2025/2. Official Gazette (Resmî Gazete), 18.07.2025.
- Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, 27.03.2024, E.2024/689, K.2024/755. Separate examination of the money claim registered with the bankruptcy estate and the title deed claim. Decision text (De Jure)
- Court of Cassation 23rd Civil Chamber, 07.03.2018, E.2015/9483, K.2018/2080. Joinder of the bankruptcy administration in the case and assessment of the bankruptcy provisions. Decision text (De Jure)
- Court of Cassation Grand General Assembly for Unification of Case Law, 25.01.1984, E.1983/3, K.1984/1. Discussion of retroactive/prospective effect of termination.
Related Güneş & Güneş publications
- Construction Contracts Guide
- Termination of Flat-for-Land Construction and Return of Title Deeds
- Objection to the Sale of Land Shares in Urban Transformation
- Title Deed Obtained from a Contractor: Good Faith of the Third Party
- Flat-for-Land (Kat Karşılığı) Construction Contract Guide
- If the Contractor Does Not Hand Over the Title Deed: Registration and Compensation
- Flat-for-Land Construction Contract in Urban Transformation