Introduction
The conflict between a bank’s right to collect its receivable and the property right of the third party who acquired the asset cannot be resolved with a single “asset-hiding” assumption. The relationship from which the bank receivable arose, the point at which the liability of the debtor and the surety began, the economic reality of the asset disposition and the grounds for annulment provided by law must each be investigated separately.
This article is based on the system of İİK Arts. 277–284 as of November 20, 2026 and on the amendment made by Law No. 7571, which entered into force on December 25, 2025; it also indicates the periods in which older case law applied.
Annulment actions in which the creditor is a public administration or a maintenance creditor are addressed in separate articles: annulment of dispositions against public receivables and transfers of property to evade a maintenance debt. This article focuses on the problems of proof specific to bank loan receivables.
The Purpose and Legal Nature of the Action for Annulment of Dispositions
The balance between protecting the creditor and freedom of disposition
Non-payment of a debt does not make every asset transaction of the debtor unlawful. The debtor may continue its commercial activity, sell assets or perform its existing obligations. Nevertheless, some transactions reduce the debtor’s assets in a way that eliminates the creditor’s satisfaction through compulsory enforcement. The Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK) seeks to resolve this conflict of interests not by prohibiting all dispositions but by making certain transactions, under certain conditions, the subject of an annulment action. It should not be forgotten that the action is an exception to ordinary freedom of contract. For this reason, the statutory grounds for annulment must not be turned into a broad and indeterminate review of morality.
Relative ineffectiveness and the fate of ownership
Granting an action for annulment of dispositions does not create an absolute nullity that removes the debtor’s transaction as against everyone. İİK Art. 283 gives the creditor the ability to seek attachment and sale of the asset that is the subject of the action. Re-registering the immovable in the debtor’s name in the land registry is, as a rule, not a necessary consequence of this protection. The purpose of the annulment action is thus not to re-establish the ownership order from the beginning but to make the enforcement opportunity of the claimant creditor workable again. The relative effect of the judgment also requires its limits to be determined with respect to the amount of the receivable and the parties.
How it differs from a claim of simulation
Under Article 19 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK), simulation concerns a conscious discrepancy between the parties’ real intention and the intention they declare outwardly. In an action based on İİK Art. 277 et seq., by contrast, the apparent transaction may have been genuinely intended and validly made. The creditor requests that the consequence of this valid transaction that obstructs compulsory enforcement against it be removed. This distinction changes both the subject of proof and the conditions of the action. In the statement of claim, simulation in the transaction and the statutory grounds for annulment must not be confused; if the same facts are relied on, the alternative legal characterizations must be set out clearly and consistently.
For the claim that the apparent sale is simulated and the route of cancelling the title: Simulated property transfer and cancellation of title.
Preconditions of the Right of Action
Proving the genuine receivable and the credit relationship
The action for annulment of dispositions rests on the capacity of creditor. For this reason, the genuineness of the receivable that is the subject of the enforcement proceedings must be demonstrated not merely by a balance appearing in the bank’s account statement but together with the contract and the disbursement documents that underlie the receivable. The bank’s commercial books, credit account movements, payment plans, default notices and collection records complement one another in this context. Objections to the amount of the receivable are not of the same nature as the allegation that the receivable never arose. Determining the debt relationship on which the action rests is also necessary in order to examine whether the disposition sought to be annulled occurred before or after the debt.
The problem of the date the debt arose
A general credit agreement often sets the framework conditions for the disbursement of credit. The day the agreement was signed and the day a particular credit risk arose do not coincide in every case. Different dates may be at issue, particularly in revolving credits, letters of guarantee, limit increases and restructurings. The termination of the account may affect the maturity of the receivable or the manner of collection, but it should not be accepted in every case as the first date on which the debt arose. The court should investigate which specific receivable arose from which disbursement and should establish a chronological link between this debt and the disposition sought to be annulled. An automatic approach that relies solely on the date of the contract may produce wrong results for both the bank and the third party.
Final enforcement proceedings and the certificate of insolvency
The function of the action for annulment of dispositions becomes apparent where the receivable could not be obtained by ordinary enforcement routes. This is why, in practice, emphasis is placed on finalized enforcement proceedings and on a provisional or final certificate of insolvency. Under İİK Art. 277, the existence of a provisional or final certificate of insolvency enables the creditor to bring an annulment action. However, whether an attachment record has the quality of a certificate of insolvency must be determined by assessing the specific content of the record and the scope of the search for attachable assets. The debtor merely not being found at its address is not the same fact as establishing that its assets are insufficient to cover the receivable.
Time limits and legal characterization
İİK Art. 284 provides that the right to bring an annulment action lapses five years after the date on which the disposition was made. In addition, Articles 278, 279 and 280 contain different periods and conditions for pursuit that are specific to each ground for annulment. It is not correct to gather all these periods under a single concept of limitation. The bank’s counsel should first determine separately the date of the disposition, the date of the attachment or insolvency, and the date the action was filed. In assessing time limits, the entry into force of statutory amendments and their temporal application should also be taken into account.
Standing in respect of the bank’s receivable, assignment and suretyship
Where the bank’s receivable has been assigned to another financial institution or to an asset management company, the claimant’s capacity as creditor, the chain of assignment, the scope of the assigned receivable and its connection with the enforcement file must be investigated. The assignment of a receivable does not by itself change the historical starting point of the debt relationship. However, the new claimant’s standing to sue and to pursue enforcement, the notification of the assignment and the debtor’s defenses must be examined specifically.
With regard to the surety, the arising of a personal debt and the surety’s acquisition of a right of subrogation/recourse against the principal debtor by paying the bank are different concepts. Without examining validity requirements such as the form of the suretyship and spousal consent, the suretyship limit, the scope of liability and which credit risk was secured, liability extending across all periods cannot be assumed merely from a signature. In an examination of annulment of dispositions, it must be specifically determined which asset of which debtor was transferred.
Genuine legal interest and the limit of collection in a secured receivable
Within the framework of İİK Art. 45, the principle of first resorting to the pledge and its exceptions; the uncollected balance, the scope of the security, enforcement proceedings commenced for the same receivable and the value of the security must be assessed together. The action is a relative protection that serves the collection of the receivable; double collection cannot be created on the same receivable. Setting out in a table the relationship among the mortgage-based enforcement, general attachment proceedings and the files against the surety is necessary for the defense of both the creditor and the transferee.
Proving the historical relationship between the general credit agreement and the specific credit disbursement
The decision of the Civil General Assembly of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu) dated 09.11.2021, E.2018/85, K.2021/1372, explained, by reference to a specific credit agreement, that the day the surety made a payment to the bank cannot in every case be regarded as the day the receivable arose. The subject of the decision is the chronology among the credit agreement dated 06.04.2007, the immovable transfer dated 29.07.2009 and the surety’s payment dated 05.03.2010. The Assembly reversed the resistance judgment that took the payment date as its starting point. The real legal value of the decision lies in its basing itself on the arising of the suretyship and credit relationship without confusing separate debt relationships.
On the other hand, if a new credit disbursement arose entirely independently after the settlement of an earlier debt, the mere existence of the earlier general credit agreement may not resolve the date the new risk arose. Each debt item in the bank’s records should be matched with the date of the disposition. Whether a limit increase is a continuation of the existing relationship or a new and independent borrowing should be reasoned on the basis of the contract, the account movements and the commercial purpose.
For the effect of a limit increase on the surety’s liability: If the credit limit is increased, does the surety’s liability increase?
The surety’s asset disposition and the principal debtor’s asset disposition are treated separately
The sale of an immovable by the principal credit debtor and the sale of an immovable by a natural person who is a surety are not the same factual case. The validity requirements of the suretyship, the limit and date from which the surety’s liability began, and the receivable for which enforcement was pursued must be established. Under TBK Art. 596, the position of a surety who pays the bank as subrogee and with a right of recourse is conceptually different from the bank being a direct creditor against the surety. Confusing the day on which the surety paid with the day on which it became liable as surety may lead to a wrong determination of whether the disposition was made before or after the debt.
Grounds for Annulment and the Regime of Proof
Gratuitous dispositions: İİK Art. 278
İİK Art. 278 brings within the scope of annulment donations and gratuitous dispositions, other than customary gifts, under the conditions set by law. The provision as amended by Law No. 7571 has reconsidered the period for transactions subject to annulment and the proof of consideration in dispositions between close persons. After the amendment, the one-year period and proof of consideration corresponding to the real value have gained importance. In assessing the groups of persons concerned and the comparison of value, the compatibility of pre-amendment case law with the text of the statute should be re-examined. In particular, in transactions between close relatives, it cannot be accepted that the abstract fact of kinship wholly excludes the examination of evidence concerning the payment of a real price.
Determining the real price
In immovable sales, the price declared in the land registry does not by itself prove the economic counter-value of the transaction. The comparable market value on the day of sale, the physical characteristics of the immovable, its zoning status, its encumbrances and the conditions of the sale should be considered together. Payments made from the transferee’s bank accounts, the amount credited to the debtor’s account, the plausibility of an alleged cash payment and financing provided by the third party are the principal evidence in the discussion of the price. In assessing proof, carrying price increases in later years back unchanged to the past sale date should be avoided. The opposite approach may make a genuine sale appear suspicious merely because of market movements that occurred afterward.
Transactions made while insolvent: İİK Art. 279
İİK Art. 279 makes certain dispositions listed in the statute by a person who does not pay its debts subject to annulment within a specified time interval. The establishment of a pledge for an existing debt that had not been previously undertaken, payment made by means other than customary means of payment, or payment of a debt that has not yet fallen due are important in this context. The statute also gives the beneficiary a defense by allowing it to prove that it did not know of the debtor’s situation. In bank practice this provision is double-edged: just as the bank may challenge security given in favor of another creditor, a new pledge established in the bank’s own favor during a credit restructuring may also be made the subject of an annulment action by third parties.
Intent to harm: İİK Art. 280
İİK Art. 280 allows the annulment of transactions made by a debtor whose assets do not cover its debts with the intent to harm its creditors, where the other party knew of this or there were obvious indications from which it should have known. The elements of intent and knowledge cannot in most cases be proved directly by written documents. The timing of the transaction, the relationship between the parties, the absence of a payment trail, the debtor’s continued use of the asset and other transfers made in the same period take on meaning together. However, kinship alone, a low price or the sale having been made close in time to the enforcement proceedings does not produce the same result in every dispute; the whole of the specific case must be the basis.
Transfer of a business and commercial continuity
The provision of İİK Art. 280 relating to the transfer of a commercial enterprise or of a significant part of the commercial goods at a business is of particular importance in banks’ commercial credit files. The continuation of the debtor company’s means of production, customer base and actual business activity under another legal entity may not be explained solely by entries in the trade registry. The shareholding structure, managers, employees, address, stock movements and payment relationships of the transferee company should be examined together. At the same time, the transfer of a business may also be an ordinary transaction of economic life. For this reason, annulment should not be inferred merely from similarity of activity without determining the conditions of the legal presumption.
Temporal application of Art. 278 after Law No. 7571
The new İİK Art. 278, which entered into force on 25.12.2025 under Article 2 of Law No. 7571, provides a one-year period counted back from the dates listed in the statute in place of the two-year arrangement of the old text. This period is not the same as the five-year forfeiture period under İİK Art. 284 running from the date of the disposition. In addition, the conditions of Articles 279 and 280 must be examined separately.
Under the new Article 278, dispositions between relatives and persons living in a shared home are deemed donations unless it is proved that consideration corresponding to the real value was paid; contracts made for a very inadequate consideration are deemed donations unless the contrary is proved. This system regulates the creditor’s allegation and the third party’s opportunity to prove the contrary together. The text in force on the date of the transfer, the statute’s provision on entry into force, applicability in time to pending cases and the effect of Constitutional Court decisions must be reasoned separately for the specific transaction. The debate on the new provision should not be presented as though a settled and uniform transitional case law exists.
Procedural distinction between annulment of dispositions and a simulation claim under TBK Art. 19
Rendering a genuine sale relatively ineffective as against the creditor and the claim that the apparent sale is simulated are not the same claim outcome. The court’s power of legal characterization is assessed together with the principles that the proceedings are limited to the specific facts relied on by the parties and that the court is bound by the relief requested. Where the preconditions of İİK Art. 277 et seq. are absent, it cannot be said that a claim under TBK Art. 19 will be accepted automatically in every case. In the petition, the material facts, the legal grounds and the requested enforcement outcome must be set out without contradiction.
Three separate presumptions of consideration in the new text of İİK Art. 278
Under İİK Art. 278 as amended by Article 2 of Law No. 7571, dispositions between relatives listed in the statute and persons living together are deemed donations unless it is proved that they were made for consideration corresponding to the real value. Second, contracts in which the debtor accepted a price that is very inadequate compared with the real value of what it gave are deemed donations unless the contrary is proved. Third, the condition of appropriate consideration is regulated separately for life annuities, usufruct and lifelong-care relationships.
The subjects of proof in these three situations are not the same: the relationship of kinship, the genuineness of the sale price and the economic counter-value of the care/annuity undertaking are established by different documents. The existence of a nominal price in the land registry record does not by itself prove the match between actual payment and real value. On the other hand, even where a presumption of kinship or of price exists, the court must give reasons for why the counter-evidence was not accepted.
The one-year suspect period and the five-year limitation period for bringing the action cannot be confused
The one-year period in the current İİK Art. 278 determines the time interval within which the gratuitous dispositions in the relevant provision are examined. The five-year forfeiture period in İİK Art. 284, by contrast, is a separate limit relating to the exercise of the right to bring an annulment action from the date of the disposition. The particular conditions and time elements of İİK Arts. 279 and 280 do not replace these two arrangements. Automatically applying the case law of the old two-year Art. 278 regime to the new period may produce errors with respect to entry into force and application to past transactions.
The Legal Position of the Third Party
Protection of good faith
In actions for annulment of dispositions, the mere fact that a third party dealt with the debtor does not mean that its interest is not worthy of legal protection. Purchase at a real price, payment documents, actual delivery, the source of financing and whether the debtor’s financial condition was externally knowable must be assessed. The presumptions provided by the statute may affect the burden of proof; but the scope of those presumptions must not be exceeded. In particular, the possibility of proving consideration under the new Art. 278 requires an examination focused on the economic reality of the transaction.
Chain transfers
Transfer of the asset first by the debtor to one person and later to another affects the parties to the action and the consequences of the judgment. İİK Art. 282 allows later persons who acted in bad faith to be joined to the action while protecting the rights of later good-faith acquirers. The claimant should not be content with asserting a defect in the first transfer alone; it should also set out the basis of the allegation directed against the later acquirer. The whole chain of transfers should be examined, with the date, price, parties and registration records for each transaction.
The third party’s defense
The defendant third party may submit evidence showing the ordinary commercial reason for the transaction, that the price was actually paid and that it did not know of the debtor’s intent to harm creditors. The effective exercise of the right of defense also contributes to making the creditor’s allegations specific. Where the burden of proof is shifted by statutory presumptions, it is a requirement of the right to a reasoned judgment and of foreseeability that the court state clearly which fact is to be proved by whom.
Counter-evidence that may secure protection of a genuine sale
The third party may document the immovable’s market value on the day of sale, bank transfers, the financing loan taken out for the sale, the state of use before and after the purchase, renovation and tax payments, the independent negotiation process and the absence of any special relationship that would have required it to learn of the seller’s debt situation. On the other hand, the existence of a payment record does not remove the possibility that the money was sent on a date and for a reason unrelated to the sale. The description, the counterparty and the flow of funds in bank receipts should be examined together. The burden of proof is not distributed in the same way depending on whether Article 278, 279 or 280 applies.
Separate examination of each link in the chain of transfers
Successive sales must not be reduced to a single collective “asset-hiding” allegation. For the first transferee and the later acquirers, the transfer date, price, payment trail, actual possession, land registry annotations and information link with the debtor must be determined separately. The structure of İİK Art. 282 protecting later good-faith acquirers and the monetary consequences of Art. 283 where the asset has been disposed of may give rise to different types of liability.
Proceedings, Interim Protection and the Effect of the Judgment
The parties to the action and the relief requested
Under İİK Art. 282, the action is directed against the debtor, the persons who dealt with it or received payment from the debtor, and the other persons specified in the statute. Correctly identifying the parties is particularly important in cases where the immovable has changed hands. In the statement of claim, the relief requested should be framed in line with the relative effect of the annulment judgment. The creditor’s aim is not to have the land registry record corrected in an absolute sense but to obtain the power of attachment and sale over the asset in question for the collection of the receivable.
Precautionary attachment and proportionality
İİK Art. 281 allows a request for precautionary attachment of the assets that are the subject of the disposition. The possibility that the asset may change hands again or lose its economic value while the action is pending increases the importance of interim legal protection. However, interim protection is not an automatic consequence of the annulment action. The request must be reasoned on the basis of the amount of the receivable, the concrete evidence concerning the transaction and the need for protection. The court should take into account the circumstances of the specific case with respect to security and the proportionality of the intervention.
For the general framework of interim legal protection: Interim injunction and precautionary attachment.
Enforcement of the judgment and the third party’s liability
Under İİK Art. 283, the annulment judgment may give the creditor the power to seek attachment and sale of the asset. Where the asset has been disposed of or enforcement against the asset itself is not possible, the monetary liability consequences provided by the statute may also arise separately. The scope of the judgment should be determined by considering together the amount of the receivable, the value of the disposition sought to be annulled and the legal position of the defendant. The judgment should not be interpreted as creating unlimited compensation in favor of the claimant creditor or a general right of claim against all of the third party’s assets.
Subject-matter jurisdiction, territorial jurisdiction, fees and the scope of res judicata
For an action for annulment of dispositions, subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction must be determined within the framework of the legal nature of the action, the capacities of the parties and the applicable procedural rules. The fact that the receivable relationship is based on a bank credit agreement does not by itself turn every dispute into a commercial case. In particular, the combination of bank, surety and third party, and whether the claim is based on İİK Art. 277 et seq. or on TBK Art. 19, may affect the procedural examination. Jurisdiction and the conditions of action should be checked specifically in the file, and the preliminary examination should not be confused with the substantive discussions of proof.
Limiting the relief requested to the receivable and its ancillary items affects the value of the action, how fees and attorney’s fees are determined, and the enforceability of the judgment. Framing the claim solely as cancellation and registration of title may not accord with the relative effect of the action. The court’s judgment must state clearly for which receivable and enforcement file, and over which asset, the power of attachment and sale is granted.
The scope of precautionary attachment and the right of property
When a protective order is requested under İİK Art. 281, the value of the asset, the scope of the receivable, the risk of transfer, sufficient prima facie proof and security must be assessed together. A lengthy precautionary attachment that in practice limits the power of disposition over the asset may affect the defendant third party’s interests under Article 35 of the Constitution. For this reason, judicial decisions on maintaining the measure must be reasoned according to the developing circumstances of the file rather than being made automatically.
Application Problems Specific to Bank Receivables
Framework agreement, disbursement and restructuring
Commercial credit relationships often do not consist of a single payment transaction. Successive disbursements may be made under a general credit agreement; an earlier debt may be tied to a new payment plan or the credit limit may be changed. These transactions make it harder to determine whether the disposition occurred before or after the debt. In examining the file, the type and dates of the credit disbursement, the continuity of the risk and the legal nature of the restructuring should be determined separately. Treating the restructuring date in every case as the arising of a new debt, or taking all disbursements back to the date of the first framework agreement, can each be misleading.
For objection to the account termination notice and the surety’s default: Account termination notice and the surety’s default in a general credit agreement.
The evidentiary value of bank records
Credit account movements, security records, notices and collection information are important for establishing the receivable. Nevertheless, it should not be assumed that the bank’s unilateral records prove all facts beyond dispute. Within the framework of the relevant procedural provisions and contractual evidence arrangements, the reliability of the documents, their consistency with one another and the counter-evidence should be examined. In particular, where payment of the sale price is alleged, although a bank transfer does not by itself prove the genuineness of the transaction in all respects, it is an important objective datum.
Enforcement and annulment of dispositions in secured receivables
If the bank’s receivable is secured by a mortgage on an immovable, the principle of first resorting to the pledge under İİK Art. 45 and its exceptions must be assessed separately. The value of the encumbered immovable, the part of the receivable left unsecured and the stage the enforcement process has reached may affect the interest requirement of the annulment action. The existence of a pledge does not make the annulment action unnecessary in every case; but the amount for which the creditor needs protection must be shown clearly. Calculation and enforcement coordination must be ensured among the enforcement files so as not to lead to double collection.
Digital evidence and data protection
In establishing asset movements, trade registry records, land registry documents, electronic correspondence and bank movements may be important. However, evidence-gathering activity must be compatible with the protection of personal data and the principles of lawfully obtained evidence. Rather than unlimited investigation of the parties’ private account movements, requesting documents connected with the dispute through the court and carrying out a proportionate examination of evidence is a more reliable method. The integrity of electronic documents, the manner in which they were obtained and the date of the transaction should be verified by technical examination where necessary.
Evidence and chronology table to follow in a bank credit file
| Transaction to be examined | Required document | Legal problem it resolves |
|---|---|---|
| General credit agreement / suretyship | Original signed agreement, annexes, limit and date information | Start of the debt relationship and of liability |
| Disbursements and limit increases | Account movements, credit receipts, risk tables | Which receivable arose in which period |
| Restructuring and account termination | Protocol, termination notice and record of service | Continuation of the existing debt or a new debt; maturity |
| Enforcement and attachment | Enforcement file, payment order, attachment records | Finalization, failure to collect and insolvency |
| Disposition and later transfers | Land registry, vehicle and registry records, sale protocol | Chain of transfers, date, person and value |
| Real consideration | Bank receipts, sources of credit, market-value report | Proof of price and statutory presumptions |
A unilateral risk statement prepared by the bank should not be regarded as having conclusively proved every date and amount unless it is verified by the contract and account movements. As regards the defendant third party as well, the official price in the land registry alone does not in every case prove the real sale consideration.
Knowledge of the debtor’s financial condition under İİK Art. 280
The third party’s ability to access the credit risk or the enforcement file is not at the same level in every transaction. The probative force of facts such as a transfer between group companies, the capacity of manager or shareholder, a joint commercial activity and the continuation of the debtor’s production and assets in the transferee company differs. The presumption of knowledge and the obvious indications must not be confused with the price/kinship regime in Art. 278. The economic reason for the transaction and the payment of consideration should also be assessed together.
Contested questions of proof for the bank and the third party
The plan of proof should be prepared around separate questions for each party rather than abstract capacities: the bank must explain which specific credit risk arose, on which date and by which document; the third party must explain where the sale price was obtained, to whom and when it was paid. The bank may show why the record having the quality of a certificate of insolvency demonstrates a failure of collection; the transferee may show the commercial or personal reason for the transaction and how actual use continued after the acquisition. The court, for its part, should discuss the conditions of İİK Arts. 278, 279 and 280 separately, without reducing them to a single holistic allegation of bad faith.
Important legal limits when tabulating the burden of proof
The general burden of proof under HMK Art. 190 and the statutory presumptions of the İİK apply together. The bank’s unilateral books and account records, merely because they are institutional documents, do not remove the transferee’s defense of payment and good faith. Likewise, the transferee’s bank receipt does not by itself prove that the price equaled the market value or that the price was not later returned to the debtor. The court should collect the records to be obtained from the bank and from third parties within the framework of the principles of proportionality and protection of private life.
Model of Proof and Critical Assessment
A chronology-based model of proof
For the bank’s counsel, the sound method is first to show the dates of the receivable and of the disposition in a single timeline. The legal dispute becomes concrete when the dates of the framework agreement, disbursement, default, account termination, enforcement, attachment, insolvency and transfer are made visible together. In the second stage, for each transfer the transferee’s identity, price, payment trail, actual use and later transfers should be determined. In the third stage, these facts should be tied separately to the provisions of İİK Arts. 278, 279 and 280. In this way, legal characterization rests on testable evidentiary propositions rather than on a general asset-hiding narrative.
The limit between the burden of proof and statutory presumptions
In the law of annulment of dispositions, presumptions reduce information asymmetry. The creditor often cannot directly access the hidden relationships between the debtor and the transferee. However, the fact that presumptions operate in the creditor’s favor should not eliminate the transferee’s right to submit effective counter-evidence. In particular, in intra-family dispositions and business transfers, absolute assumptions that go beyond the scope drawn by the statute may be problematic with respect to the right of property and legal certainty. A distinction must be made between facilitating proof and wholly eliminating the burden of proof.
Assessment of the amendment made by Law No. 7571
The amendment to İİK Art. 278 has created a need for fresh interpretation with respect to gratuitous transactions subject to annulment and dispositions between close persons. The effect of the one-year period on practice brings with it a debate about a new balance between the scope of creditor protection and legal certainty. The problem of temporal application for transactions before the amendment also requires separate examination. Before settled case law on the new provision has formed, transposing the reasoning of old decisions unchanged to the current text is methodologically problematic. For this reason, it is important that courts set out their transitional-law reasoning clearly.
Example case
Assume that a natural person who is a surety for a company’s commercial credit debt transfers the immovable to a close relative, continues to use the immovable after the transfer, and there is no reliable record that the price was paid. The bank has not been able to identify other attachable assets in the enforcement file. In this case, the first question is whether the surety’s personal debt validly arose and whether the transfer took place after that debt. The second question is the status of the attachment record as a certificate of insolvency. The third question is whether the sale was made for a real price and what the third party knew of the debtor’s situation. Granting annulment solely on the basis of the kinship relationship and the land registry transfer, without answering these questions, would leave the system of proof incomplete.
Proposed assessment criterion
In an action for annulment of dispositions, the court should discuss separately, for each ground for annulment, the applicable statutory text, the dates of the case, the burden of proof and the evidence submitted. The bank, for its part, should keep apart the documents explaining the genuineness of the receivable and the enforcement process from the evidence showing the economic content of the transfer. This method both reduces unnecessary prolongation of the action and makes the third party’s defense specific. The effectiveness of compulsory enforcement can be secured not by lowering the standard of evidence but by correctly determining the subject of proof.
Court of Cassation Case Law, Opposing Views and Legal Conclusion
The effect of Court of Cassation decisions on the specific dispute
Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) Civil General Assembly, 09.11.2021, E.2018/85, K.2021/1372. The claimant turned against the principal debtor after the payment it had made to the bank as surety. The dispute concerns which of the credit agreement date and the surety’s payment date is to be taken as the basis for the annulment of dispositions. In the specific case, the Civil General Assembly took the credit agreement as the basis for the arising of the debt and reversed the local court’s resistance judgment. The decision should not be generalized without limit to mean that, in every different credit agreement, all risks automatically arise on the date of the first general agreement. Source: decision record (dejure.ai).
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E.2022/11606, K.2023/2626. In the course of the proceedings, an error consisting in taking the account termination date in place of the date the debt arose was discussed. In the final appellate review, the Chamber affirmed the judgment granting the claim that had been issued in line with the reversal. For this reason, the earlier reversal reasoning and the final affirmation result must not be substituted for one another. Source: decision record (dejure.ai).
Court of Cassation 17th Civil Chamber, 05.11.2015, E.2014/4341, K.2015/11588. The relationship of subsequent disbursements and limit increases in a general credit relationship to the initial agreement was assessed. In the specific case, the Chamber did not find it appropriate to defer the arising of the debt merely by relying on the dates of later disbursements. Source: decision record (dejure.ai).
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, 16.12.2024, E.2024/6522, K.2024/12977. Because there was no duly issued attachment record and certificate of insolvency in the enforcement file, whether the conditions necessary for reaching the merits of the annulment action had been met was decisive. The decision shows that a general statement that the bank had no remaining possibility of collection is not sufficient on its own. Source: decision record (dejure.ai).
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, 27.03.2023, E.2022/16090, K.2023/4429. Evidence such as bank transactions supporting the third party’s purchase of the immovable at a real price, acquaintance and actual use was assessed. Counter-evidence of this kind shows that bad faith or gratuitousness cannot be presumed automatically in every case. Source: decision record (dejure.ai).
The temporal limit of case law: The two-year period and the old statutory presumptions in decisions based on the text of İİK Art. 278 before 25.12.2025 should not be transposed directly to transactions after Law No. 7571. In using decisions, the material facts, the statutory period applied, the result of reversal or affirmation and the article to which the reasoning is genuinely tied should be recorded separately.
Comparative result of the case law: The decision of the Civil General Assembly dated 09.11.2021 shows that the surety’s later payment to the bank did not move the starting point to the payment day in the credit relationship examined. On the other hand, it is not correct to apply this principle automatically to every new disbursement and every independent debt. The decision of the 17th Civil Chamber dated 05.11.2015 goes to proof of a continuing credit relationship, while the decision of the 4th Civil Chamber dated 16.12.2024 goes to the separate proof of the insolvency condition even where the credit receivable exists. The decisions should be assessed not as general conclusory sentences used interchangeably but as authorities resolving different legal questions.
Assessing opposing defenses together
For the bank: The existence of the credit receivable, the enforcement and insolvency, the disposition having taken place after the debt, and the specific ground for annulment under Arts. 278–280 must be shown. Kinship, a sale below market value and a transfer immediately before the enforcement may be mutually supporting indications; but the same burden of proof does not apply to each ground for annulment.
For the debtor and the transferee: Allegations such as a difference in the date and scope of the debt, independent purchase financing, payment of the real sale price, economic need, the actual use having passed to the transferee, lack of knowledge of the intent to harm the creditor, or falling outside the statutory one-year period may be examined on separate legal grounds. The transaction being genuine does not by itself exclude all possibilities of annulment, particularly with respect to Art. 280; the converse is also true.
For the court: For each allegation, the reasoning should state which fact is to be proved by whom, which evidence answers which question and why counter-evidence is accepted or rejected. Statutory presumptions and the free evaluation of evidence do not eliminate one another.
Conclusion
The action for annulment of dispositions is an important but exceptional legal protection for banks’ ability to collect their credit receivables. The relative effect of the action does not eliminate third-party ownership in an absolute sense; it grants enforcement power to a particular creditor where the statutory conditions are met. In this respect, annulment of dispositions is distinct from nullity based on a claim of simulation.
In bank receivables, the date the debt arose cannot be automatically equated with the date the general credit agreement was signed or the date the account was terminated. Disbursement and restructuring processes must be examined with respect to the specific receivable. Without establishing the connection among the genuine receivable, enforcement, insolvency and the date of the disposition, the assessment of the grounds for annulment remains incomplete. Because İİK Arts. 278, 279 and 280 provide different conditions, the statement of claim and the reasoning of the judgment must explain the applicability of each provision separately.
İİK Art. 278, as amended by Law No. 7571, has begun a new period of interpretation for gratuitous dispositions and transactions between close persons. In carrying evaluations based on the old text over to the new provision, time limits, the possibility of proof and temporal application should be handled with care. Finally, the balance to be struck between protection of the creditor and the third party’s right of property and right of defense determines the legitimacy of the institution of annulment of dispositions. An effective bank counsel strategy should rest not on general allegations of bad faith but on a verifiable transaction chronology, objective payment records and the concretization of the statutory grounds for annulment.
For the scope of work in the collection of bank receivables and in actions for annulment of dispositions, our pages on enforcement and bankruptcy law and banking and finance law may be consulted.
Frequently Asked Questions
What must a bank prove in order to bring an action for annulment of dispositions?
It must show the existence of a genuine receivable and of the required enforcement/insolvency conditions, that the debt arose before the disposition, and at least one specific ground for annulment under İİK Art. 278, 279 or 280. The conditions of proof differ for each provision.
Is the date of the general credit agreement or the date of account termination taken as the basis?
The account termination date is mostly important for maturity and enforcement. Decisions such as the Civil General Assembly’s decision dated 09.11.2021 took the agreement date as the basis in particular credit relationships. However, which receivable arose from which agreement/disbursement or suretyship must be established specifically.
If there is no certificate of insolvency, can the action not be brought?
Under İİK Art. 277, a provisional or final certificate of insolvency, or an attachment record of the kind the statute accepts, is important. The Court of Cassation’s practice on obtaining the document and submitting it to the proceedings should be examined separately. Not every unsuccessful attachment attempt is automatically a certificate of insolvency.
After Law No. 7571, is a sale to a close relative necessarily annulled?
No. The new Art. 278 contains a special provision on proving that dispositions between the persons listed in the statute were made for consideration corresponding to the real value. The statutory one-year period, the other conditions and an alternative claim under Art. 280 are assessed separately.
Does a judgment annulling a disposition directly return the land registry entry to the former owner?
As a rule, no. Under İİK Art. 283, a relative effect arises in favor of the claimant creditor concerning the power of attachment and sale over the asset. The request and the judgment must be limited to the amount of the receivable and the specific asset.
If the transferee paid the sale price through a bank, is the action dismissed?
A mere receipt is not sufficient in every case; whether the price was the real sale consideration, the market value, the relationship of the parties, the time of payment and the conditions of use are examined. However, proof of consideration is a strong defense evidence.
If the debt was restructured, is the earlier debt deemed to have been extinguished?
Not in every case. Whether the restructuring is a continuation of the old debt or is of a nature that creates a new debt must be determined from the contract and the payment records.
From when does the five-year period for bringing the action run?
The forfeiture period under İİK Art. 284 runs from the date of the disposition. This period must not be confused with the one-year look-back period relating to a particular ground for annulment under Art. 278.
Which date matters in the transfer of an immovable by a person who is a surety for a bank credit?
The legally valid establishment of the suretyship and the credit debt to which it relates, the arising of the principal debt and the transfer of the immovable are assessed separately. As in the decision of the Civil General Assembly dated 09.11.2021, the surety’s later payment to the bank does not by itself move the starting point of the debt to the payment date in the specific case.
If there is a mortgage, can the bank bring an action for annulment of dispositions?
The existence of a mortgage is not by itself an absolute bar. İİK Art. 45, the form of the enforcement, the risk secured by the mortgage and what amount of the receivable remains uncovered are examined. Double enforcement is not permitted on amounts that have been collected.
What happens if the immovable has been transferred to a third person after the sale?
Under İİK Arts. 282 and 283, the later transferee’s good faith, its position in the chain of transfers and the possibilities of monetary liability arising from the asset having been disposed of are assessed separately. The allegation that the first transfer is subject to annulment does not mean that every later acquisition is automatically ineffective.
Can precautionary attachment be requested in an action for annulment of dispositions?
Under İİK Art. 281, interim protection may be requested over the asset or right that is the subject of the disposition. The court must examine proportionality with respect to the scope of the receivable, prima facie proof, security and the third party’s right of property.
Sources
Legislation
- Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, in particular Art. 45 and Arts. 277–284.
- Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, in particular Art. 19.
- Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100.
- Law No. 7571, Art. 2, Official Gazette, December 25, 2025, No. 33118.
- Constitution of the Republic of Türkiye, in particular Arts. 35 and 36.
Official online sources
- Legislation Information System (Mevzuat Bilgi Sistemi) (accessed: November 19, 2026).
- Official Gazette (Resmî Gazete) (accessed: November 19, 2026).
- Court of Cassation Decision Search (Yargıtay Karar Arama) (accessed: November 19, 2026).
- Court of Cassation Civil General Assembly, 09.11.2021, E. 2018/85, K. 2021/1372. Full decision.
- Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/11606, K. 2023/2626.
- Court of Cassation 17th Civil Chamber, 05.11.2015, E. 2014/4341, K. 2015/11588.
- Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, 16.12.2024, E. 2024/6522, K. 2024/12977.
- Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, 27.03.2023, E. 2022/16090, K. 2023/4429.
- Law No. 7571, Official Gazette, 25.12.2025, No. 33118, Art. 2.