A fiduciary transfer (inançlı işlem) may come into question where a property has really been transferred, but it has been agreed that it will be returned when a specific purpose ends or a condition is met. A claim that rests only on the statement "I entrusted the title deed" is not enough. The claim must explain which agreement the duty to re-transfer is based on, when that duty arose, how it will be proven and against whom it should be directed. [1, 2, 3]
In a fiduciary transfer, the transfer of ownership and the duty to return are considered together. The trustor (inanan kişi) transfers a right for a particular purpose; the trustee (inanılan kişi) must use that right in line with the agreement and return it under the agreed conditions. This structure must be distinguished both from a simulation (muvazaa) in which no transfer was wanted from the outset and from an ordinary sale of property that was not concluded in the required form.
Here, the actual transfer of the title and the transferee's contractual duty to return it complement each other. The mere fact that the title is held by another person neither establishes nor rules out a fiduciary transfer. The legal question is what the parties agreed at the first transfer and which obligation the transferee undertook.
In Which Property Disputes Does a Fiduciary Transfer Arise?
Transfer for Security
A transfer of property to secure a debt, with an agreement that it will be returned once the debt is paid, is one example. However, not every below-value sale or every transfer made by a debtor is automatically a fiduciary transfer. The parties' re-transfer agreement and the debt to which it is tied must be identified.
A transfer of property may also have been agreed as actual performance of a debt. In that case, saying "there was a transaction related to the debt" does not prove an obligation to return. A definitive transfer must be separated from a temporary transfer for security, based on the contract and the payment records. The explanations in the article on registration of title based on a right of repurchase may be used for comparison.
That the registry shows a sale does not by itself resolve what the real reason was; the trust document, the credit relationship, the payment trail, delivery and actual use are assessed together.
Registration in Another Person's Name and the Claim of Trust
When the price of a property was paid by one person but the property was registered in another person's name, this may raise a fiduciary relationship if there is also an agreement to return it. However, paying the price does not by itself make someone the owner of the title or guarantee that they will receive the property back. The payment may rest on a gift, a loan, a partnership contribution or another relationship.
Proving the source of the price paid and proving the existence of the duty to return are different matters.
For this reason, alongside the question of who financed the purchase, it is examined why the title was issued in another person's name and under what conditions it was agreed to be transferred back. Whether the transaction served an unlawful purpose may also be assessed separately; a fiduciary characterization does not automatically validate every purpose. [1] For details, the article on unauthorised or irregular transfer of company property may also be read.
Limits of Freedom of Contract
A trust agreement may create a valid obligation within the limits of TBK Articles 26–27. However, fraudulent purposes, breaches of mandatory rules and transactions aimed at defeating the rights of third parties require separate legal examination. Characterising a transaction as fiduciary does not by itself make a prohibited purpose lawful. [1]
How Are Fiduciary Transfer, Simulation and Promise of Sale Distinguished?
| Relationship | Core intent | Main dispute |
|---|---|---|
| Fiduciary transfer | Actual transfer of the right and a conditional duty to return it | Re-transfer agreement, condition and proof |
| Simulation (muvazaa) | The result stated in the apparent transaction is not in fact intended | True common intent and invalidity of the apparent transaction |
| Promise of sale | Duty to conclude a sale in the future | Valid form of the promise, conditions of performance and annotation (şerh) |
| Sale outside the land registry (haricî satış) | Sale agreement made outside the land registry | Formal requirements and any special legal consequences |
| Annulment of a disposition under İİK Article 277 et seq. | Relative ineffectiveness against the creditor | Claim, insolvency, grounds for annulment, enforcement proceedings and time limits |
Terms such as "action for cancellation of title" can be used in all of these disputes, but their factual bases are not the same. In a fiduciary transfer, the registration at the outset cannot be called unlawful merely because it rests on a relationship of trust. The problem is usually that the duty to return, assumed after a valid transfer, has not been performed.
Where more than one legal characterisation is asserted for the same event, the facts, the claims and the rules of proof must be separated consistently. Although under HMK Article 33 the legal characterisation belongs to the court, material facts that have not been asserted cannot be expected to be completed by the court on its own motion.
For more on this subject, see the article on property purchased outside the formal process and its title registration.
A written evidence approach to a trust document does not mean that the transfer of title requires no formal procedure. Establishing the registration itself and proving the duty to return are different matters. Where registration is sought on the basis of a court judgment, Article 716 of Law No. 4721 Turkish Civil Code (TMK) is also considered. [2]
Why a Judgment Annulling an Earlier Disposition May Not Prove the Trust Agreement
An action brought under İİK Article 277 et seq. addresses the question of rendering the disposition ineffective with respect to the creditor, in order to protect the creditor. In a fiduciary transfer action, by contrast, the existence and scope of the duty to return between the parties is in dispute. That a disposition is open to annulment against a creditor does not necessarily show that there is a duty to return between the transferor and the transferee. The parties to the earlier action, the facts asserted in it and the res judicata effect of the judgment are examined separately.
Why Is Written Evidence Decisive?
In the Court of Cassation's practice on fiduciary transfers, the unifying decision of February 5, 1947 (E.1945/20, K.1947/6) is one of the principal points of reference. This principle is applied in the 2024 decisions set out below. The written proof of a trust relationship and the supplementary means of proof available where there is an initial written evidence (delil başlangıcı) must be kept distinct. [3, 4, 5]
A trust agreement is proved by written evidence, without being confused with the mandatory official form for a title transfer. In its 2026 decision, the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) stresses that the trust document must bear the signature of the persons who are parties to the agreement or of the trustee. This principle cannot be stretched to allow a sale outside the land registry. [8, 9]
What Should a Trust Document Contain?
The clear details of the property, the parties, the purpose of the transfer, the condition for return, the amount of any debt, the payment schedule and the timing of the re-transfer should all be understandable. A vague note such as "I received it in trust" can create significant dispute if it does not identify which property it concerns. The signatures and the original of the document are also important.
Although it matters that a document bears the signatures of all the parties, in the Court of Cassation's formulation above a document bearing the trustee's signature is also important. A one-sided statement by an unrelated third party does not have the same status.
It should not be generalised that every trust document must be drawn up before a notary. However, the type of the document, its signature, its content and the nature of the legal relationship all affect its probative value. The existence of a notarial act does not by itself mean that the document sets out the conditions of re-transfer.
Notarial certification likewise does not by itself cure a deficiency in the content, in the condition for return or in the authority of a representative.
Does a Close Family Relationship Replace Written Evidence?
Trust within a family does not remove the need for legal proof. The rules on proof by document (Articles 200–203 of Law No. 6100 on Civil Procedure (HMK)), on counter-proof against a document and on exceptions, must be considered together, depending on the nature of the dispute. An approach such as "we are siblings, so no document is needed" or "we are relatives, so a witness is always enough" is not safe. [6]
It is particularly important how the apparent official transaction is reconciled with the claimed duty to return. The presence of witnesses does not justify skipping the review of written documents or initial written evidence. The concrete file must show which exception to the proof rules applies, and why.
Do WhatsApp Messages and E-mails Prove a Fiduciary Transfer?
Electronic data may constitute a document within the meaning of HMK Article 199. However, not every document proves a matter conclusively on its own. Initial written evidence under HMK Article 202 is a document that, although it does not fully prove the alleged legal transaction, makes it probable, and that originates from the opposing party or its representative. Where these conditions are met, supplementary proof by witness testimony may be possible. [6]
Three Checks for Initial Written Evidence
First, it must be determined from which person or representative the record originates. Second, the link between the content and the specific property and duty to return that is alleged must be examined. Third, the record must genuinely make the legal transaction probable. A money transfer alone, or the appearance of the word "trust", "debt" or "sale", does not in every case make a duty to re-transfer probable.
When Can a Witness Be Heard?
Where there is initial written evidence meeting HMK Article 202, supplementary proof by witnesses becomes possible. The statutory exceptions in HMK Article 203 must be assessed separately; a categorical bar on witnesses, or a categorical freedom to call them, should not be accepted for every close family or relationship of trust. Witness testimony and the existence of initial written evidence capable of proving the alleged legal transaction are separate preconditions. [6]
2024/5689: Messages and Witnesses Together Were Found Sufficient
In its decision of December 12, 2024 (E.2024/195, K.2024/5689), the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay 7. Hukuk Dairesi) accepted the opposing party's positive reply to correspondence seeking the return of the title as initial written evidence. The fiduciary relationship was considered proven together with witness testimony explaining who paid the price of the property and how the registration was arranged, and the rejection was quashed. [3]
This decision does not mean that any WhatsApp screenshot is enough to recover title. The sender, the recipient, the link to the property, the whole conversation and the opposing party's acceptance all matter. The file should present not a single sentence but context that shows its meaning.
2024/3183: Vague Correspondence Did Not Produce the Same Result
In its decision of June 4, 2024 (E.2023/4141, K.2024/3183), the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation discussed the fact that the correspondence could not be clearly tied to the property, an unsigned protocol and other evidence; the rejection was upheld. On the oath as well, the court stressed that the defendants were not parties to the trust relationship and that an oath must concern facts relating to the person who takes it. [4]
Read together, the two decisions show that the name of the tool does not determine the outcome. Instead of saying "there is WhatsApp", it must be explained why that message makes the duty to re-transfer probable. Sentences that concern another property, another debt or an unconcluded settlement discussion do not carry the same weight.
Integrity of the Electronic Record
The telephone number and the attribution of the account, the chronological order and the complete conversation must be preserved. Cut or altered images may weaken the proof. Access to someone else's account without permission must be avoided; records lawfully obtained must be submitted in the proper manner. Technical examination and access to the original of the document may be requested where necessary.
Limits of Evidence by Oath
Where there is no initial written evidence or written document, evidence by oath may come into play. However, HMK Article 225 and the following provisions limit the subject of the oath, the capacity as a party and the facts that must originate from the person. The scope of an oath to be administered to a person who is not a party to the relationship in dispute cannot be widened on its own. The procedural opportunities at the stage of the list of evidence and the investigation must also be taken into account. [6]
What Can Be Done If the Original of the Protocol Is With the Opposing Party?
A claim that the original of a document is in the opposing party's hands is assessed within the framework of the rules on document production. The document must be identified, and it must be explained who holds it and why there is reason to believe so. The court's order to produce the document, the duty to explain, and the consequences of refusing to produce it are examined under HMK Articles 219–220; neither automatic acceptance nor automatic rejection is assumed. [6]
In its decision of November 11, 2024 (E.2024/4867, K.2024/6128), the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay 1. Hukuk Dairesi) asked for an investigation into whether the originals of the protocols relied on by the parties were held by the defendant. Other lawsuits arising from the same document and the status of electronic records as initial evidence were also made the subject of assessment; the decision was quashed for incomplete examination. [5]
In this example, the existence of a copy of the protocol did not amount to a definitive win of the case. The original of the document, its attribution, its relation to other files and supplementary evidence must be investigated. The conclusion that "the original is not with me, so proof is no longer possible" may also be premature.
2024–2026 Court of Cassation Decisions: Accepting and Rejecting Initial Written Evidence
Court of Cassation 1st Civil Chamber, March 10, 2026, E.2024/3158, K.2026/1907: A Statement in Another Case Was Not Treated as Initial Written Evidence
In the decision, a company's share in a property was first transferred to another person; the plaintiffs claimed that this transfer was made by a fiduciary transfer so that it would be returned. In the earlier action to annul a disposition, there is a statement by the company's authorised representative that the transfer was made without consideration and in order to defer the debt. The court of first instance and the regional court of appeal reached results favouring the plaintiffs on the fiduciary transfer claim. The Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), however, held that there was no signed written evidence proving the trust agreement and that the statement in the earlier file was not initial written evidence within the meaning of HMK Article 202 in this case. [9]
Operative result of the decision: The regional court of appeal's decision rejecting the appeal on the merits was set aside, and the decision of the court of first instance was quashed. The Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) did not itself issue a new final first-instance judgment dismissing the case. This distinction matters for describing the nature of the quashing decision correctly.
The Subject of the Fact Asserted in the Earlier Case
An action to annul a disposition aims to protect the creditor's ability to enforce compulsorily. A fiduciary transfer claim, on the other hand, requires a contractual duty to return between the transferor and the transferee. A statement of a transfer without consideration that was accepted in the first dispute does not by itself confirm the decisive re-transfer agreement of the second dispute.
Why a Statement by a Company Representative Is Not Automatically Initial Written Evidence
HMK Article 202 requires that the document make the asserted legal transaction probable and originate from the person against whom it is used or from that person's representative. A statement made by a company representative in another dispute is not the same as an undertaking to return that originates from the defendant trustee personally. Whether the statement is in favour of or against the plaintiff, the capacities of the parties in the other case and its connection with the alleged agreement are separate matters for examination.
Why the Witness Testimony Was Not Enough for the Result
Where there is no initial written evidence making the alleged agreement to return probable, the existence of the agreement could not be accepted merely on witnesses' accounts of "trust" or "confidence". This result cannot be stretched to mean that witnesses can never be heard in any fiduciary transfer case; the conditions of HMK Articles 202 and 203 are applied separately.
Comparison Between the Decisions
| Decision | Decisive feature | Limited conclusion that can be drawn |
|---|---|---|
| 7th Civil Chamber 2024/5689 | Correspondence originating from the opposing party concerning return | Initial written evidence and supplementary evidence possible |
| 7th Civil Chamber 2024/3183 | Vague correspondence, unsigned protocol | The mere existence of a document is not enough |
| 1st Civil Chamber 2024/6128 | Original of the protocol and investigation of the related file | An incomplete investigation of evidence may affect the judgment |
| 1st Civil Chamber 2026/1907 | Statement in the file of another action to annul a disposition | No automatic initial written evidence for proving the agreement to return |
A Statement Made in an Earlier File: Admission, Res Judicata and Evidentiary Effect
The Link Between an In-Court Admission, the Fact and the Case
Under HMK Article 188, an admission concerns a party's acceptance of a particular fact. The extent to which a statement made in one case has consequences in another is examined by reference to the proceedings in which it was made, the parties, the capacity of agency and representation, the content of the fact and the procedural rules. The conclusion "undertook to return" cannot be drawn directly from the statement "we transferred it without consideration".
Limits of Substantive Res Judicata
Where the parties, the cause of action and the relief sought in the earlier final judgment are not the same as in the later fiduciary transfer action, the effect of res judicata is examined separately. That the same property appeared in the earlier proceedings does not show that all legal relationships were conclusively resolved. The historical facts in the reasoning of the judgment must be kept separate from the existence of the duty to return that is in dispute.
Deregistration of a Company from the Commercial Register and the Parties to the Action
Capacity of a Company Struck Off the Register to Be a Party
Where a company has been deregistered from the commercial register, the legal position of its legal personality and capacity to be a party is examined by reference to whether the liquidation has been completed and whether the commercial register entry can be revived. Which procedure applies under TTK Article 547 and the related provisions depends on the type of company and the reason for deregistration. A company's removal from the register does not automatically allow its partners to bring personally rights over the company's assets as personal claims. [11]
Personal Right of Action of the Company's Partners
Where the property belongs to the company, it must be clearly determined whether the party to the trust relationship is the company or the partner. That a partner has an economic interest does not by itself suffice for the partner to ask for the property to be registered in his or her own name. Standing to sue, representation and the possibility of reviving the company must be examined at separate stages.
When Does the Duty to Return Arise?
The obligation may be tied to a specific date, to the payment of a debt, to the realisation of a purpose or to another event. Until that condition is met, a claim for re-transfer may be premature. Where the agreement appears to be open-ended, the end of the relationship, the right to demand return and the way in which the claim became due must be assessed separately.
Performance of the Trustor's Own Obligation
Where the property was transferred as security for a debt, whether the debt has been paid matters. Under Article 97 of Law No. 6098 Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK), in a reciprocal contract the condition to perform one's own obligation, or to offer to perform it, may arise. Whether the court will order a measure such as deposit is assessed together with the existence and amount of the debt. [1]
It is not enough for a person to say that they have paid; it must show which debt has been discharged. If the transferee raises other claims, their relationship to the conditional re-transfer is explained. A debt that in fact does not exist, or that has already been paid, should not be accepted as an unclear ground for blocking the re-transfer.
When Does the Limitation Period Start in a Fiduciary Transfer?
For a personal claim to re-transfer arising from a trust relationship, the general ten-year limitation period is applied in practice. Under TBK Articles 146 and 149, the starting point is the maturity (muacceliyet) of the claim. For this reason, the date of the first transfer of the title is not automatically taken as the starting point in every case. The return condition, the date of the demand and the conduct of the debtor are examined together. [1]
For example, if it was agreed that re-transfer would take place once the debt has been fully paid, the relationship must be linked to the date of payment. On the other hand, if return was demanded long ago and expressly refused, the fact that the parties are still negotiating may not mean that the period never began. Saying in every file that "the trust relationship continues" does not remove the review of maturity and limitation.
A notarial demand letter (ihtar) may be significant for evidence and default, but not every demand letter interrupts limitation. The grounds for interruption under TBK Article 154 are also taken into account. Filing a lawsuit, acknowledgement of the claim, and ordinary reminder correspondence based on other legal grounds must be distinguished. [1]
How Are the Correct Defendant and the Claim Determined?
The person who owes the re-transfer and the current registered owner may not be the same person. Where the property has been sold to another person, the effect of the personal trust relationship on the third party and the third party's knowledge are examined separately. The good or bad faith of the subsequent buyer, the legal nature of the first registration and the result sought must be explained; a claim to annul all sales should not be filed without such explanation. TMK Articles 1023–1024 are considered in matters of reliance on a register where its conditions are met. [2]
If the title cannot be recovered, a claim for the price or for damages arising from breach of the obligation may come into question. However, requiring the current owner to assume all debts under a personal trust agreement, or requiring the former debtor to transfer a title that he or she no longer owns, raises the same level of problem. The defendant for each claim must be determined separately.
Concrete Evidence of Good Faith
The land registry, who actually used the property, whether the price was really paid, the subsequent buyer's closeness to the first parties, the timing of the transfer and the manner in which notices were served may all matter. The presumption of good faith and the proof of bad faith should not be reduced to an abstract allegation of kinship or a low price. [2]
Claim for Price and Damages if Transfer of Title Is Not Possible
Where re-registration is legally or practically impossible, a claim for the price or for damages for breach of contract may come into question. Under TBK Article 112 and the following provisions, issues such as the debtor's liability, causation, damage, the date of valuation and impossibility of performance must be examined. The claim directed at the current owner and the monetary claim directed at the former trustee should be kept separate, and framing the claim in the alternative should be considered at the outset of the case. [1]
The Significance of the 2026 Partial Amendment Decision
In its decision of May 8, 2026 (E.2021/8, K.2026/1), the Grand General Assembly for Unification of Case Law of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay İçtihatları Birleştirme Büyük Genel Kurulu) held that a new claim which was not requested at the outset cannot be added to the case by partial amendment (kısmi ıslah). The initial petition should not be left incomplete on the assumption that a monetary claim may be added to a title claim later. The decision does not mean that all amendment routes are abolished, or that HMK Article 125 on the case during proceedings no longer applies. [7]
In an ordinary title dispute, the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi) is the court with exclusive territorial jurisdiction where the property is located; provisional measures, if necessary, and valid representation of the parties are also considered. Whether the underlying relationship is commercial or otherwise of a special private nature must be examined separately for subject-matter jurisdiction and conditions of the claim. Court fees, site inspection and expert costs are planned according to the value of the claim. For the decision to be applied in the land registry, finality is required where the decision concerns a right in rem. [6]
For related topics, see our articles on simulated transfer of immovable property (muvazaalı taşınmaz devri), cancellation of title due to abuse of a power of attorney and recovery of a property donated, as well as our page on actions for cancellation and re-registration of title.
Filing the Action, Alternative Claims, Interim Injunction and Amendment
Determining the Court Where the Property Is Located in Antalya and Across Türkiye
For a claim for cancellation of title and registration based on a fiduciary transfer concerning a property in Antalya, Kemer, Alanya, Manavgat or any other province of Türkiye, the exclusive jurisdiction regime under HMK Article 12 for actions concerning real rights in immovable property is taken into account. That the plaintiff or the defendant lives in Antalya does not automatically give the Antalya courts jurisdiction over a property in another province. As for a claim solely for the price or damages arising from the trust agreement, whether the exclusive jurisdiction rule specific to a bare title registration claim applies automatically is examined separately, by reference to the nature of the claim asserted, connection and the special jurisdiction rules. The competent court (görevli mahkeme) should likewise be determined not by where the property is, but by the parties and the nature of the underlying legal relationship. [6]
Title and Evidence Preparation for Properties in Antalya
The province, district, neighbourhood, block, parcel, unit and share details of the property must be obtained correctly; the history of title transfers and the encumbrances must be matched against current records. The parties' correspondence, notarial notices, bank payment documents, the company's authority of representation and the condition on which re-transfer was made dependent must be compared. That the firm is based in Antalya does not change the jurisdiction of the court where the property is located or the legal regime nationwide. The organisation of procedures and hearings is planned according to the procedure of the relevant court and the conditions for power of attorney.
Framing the Claim for Cancellation and Registration of Title Together with a Claim for the Price
If the petition contemplates primary cancellation and registration of the title and, should that not be achieved, a claim for the price or damages, the conditions for alternative claims under HMK Article 111 should be assessed. The owner who is the addressee of the title claim and the person liable for breach of contract may be different. Court fees, the amount claimed and valuation principles are examined separately. [6]
Interim Injunction and Transfer of the Property to a Later Person
If there is a need to prevent the property in dispute from being transferred to later persons, the conditions of a request for an interim injunction must be set out concretely within HMK Articles 389–397. The scope of the injunction, security, prima facie proof and the effect on the rights of third parties must be assessed together. That an injunction is granted does not mean the main action will necessarily be allowed. [6]
Evidence and Proof Plan: Which Documents Should the Plaintiff and the Defendant Submit?
| Matter to be examined | Evidence on the plaintiff's side | Counter-evidence on the defendant's side |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement to return | Signed trust document, messages, e-mails, correspondence originating from the party | Final sale agreement, integrity of the contract, other legal purpose |
| Link with the property | Title details, date of transfer, statements of the parties | Context relating to another property or a different debt |
| Security/debt relationship | Bank receipt, payment plan, document showing the debt was discharged | A different claim, an unpaid debt, a gift or a partnership contribution |
| Company capacity | Register records, authority documents, revival decisions | Deregistration, standing to sue and objection to representation |
| Later transfer | History of title transfers, notices and correspondence, sale price | Genuine payment of the price, independent purchase, good faith |
| Maturity | Fulfilment of the condition, notice, payment and demand records | A condition that has not yet been fulfilled, a continuing debt |
| Electronic evidence | Full transcript of the conversation, ownership of the device and account | Integrity of the record, context, objection that it was unlawfully obtained |
Each piece of evidence should be tied into the file by stating which legal element it is submitted to prove. A payment receipt should not be treated as sufficient on its own, without an additional explanation of the existence of the agreement to return.
Concrete Examples of Application
An Express Undertaking to Return by Message
Person A has a property whose price he paid registered in B's name. B writes A a message, verified as having been sent, concerning a specific property: "when the debt is finished I will transfer the title to you." Even if this message does not by itself prove all the conditions, it may qualify as initial written evidence under HMK Article 202; it may be assessed together with evidence of the price, delivery and witnesses.
A Money Transfer Alone and Family Closeness
A sends money to B's account; B buys the property in his own name. The parties are close relatives but no agreement on re-transfer appears. In this case the registration cannot be ordered without determining whether the payment was made for a fiduciary transfer or for a gift, a loan or a joint investment. Even if the exceptions in HMK Article 203 come into play, they do not take the place of the existence of the underlying relationship.
A Company Transfer Subject to a Final Judgment Annulling a Disposition
A company transfers its property to a third party during a process of deferring its debts. The earlier action to annul the disposition becomes final. Later the company claims that the property was transferred fiduciarily. Even if the earlier judgment examined the lack of consideration or the harm to the creditor, the duty to return must still be proved separately by written evidence or by properly obtained initial written evidence. The 2026 decision of the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) points to this distinction. [9]
Conclusion
A strong file in a fiduciary transfer sets out, together, the agreement for return, the maturity of the debt and the appropriate means of proof. Paying the price, a close family relationship or a single message does not by itself resolve every dispute. Written documents, initial written evidence originating from the opposing party, supplementary witnesses and payment records must be linked to one another. Directing the title claim and any alternative monetary claim at the right persons from the outset reduces procedural problems that later become difficult to remedy.
The touchstone of actions for cancellation and registration of title based on a fiduciary transfer is not to whom the property was transferred, but which undertaking to return is proved by which evidence. Where the title has really been transferred, the duty to return must be distinguished from the transfer of ownership. Taken together, the 1947 Decision Unifying Case Law, HMK Articles 199–203 and the 2024–2026 decisions of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) show that not every piece of correspondence can be treated as initial written evidence, that under appropriate conditions supplementary proof by witnesses is possible, and that a final judgment in another case does not by itself establish the existence of a trust relationship. Before filing the action, the evidence, the parties, the history of title transfers, the condition for return, limitation and the alternative claim should be checked. The resolution of the dispute depends less on the narrative of the claim's justice than on legally establishing this chain of proof.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it enough to say I entrusted the title deed?
No. The content of the agreement for return, its connection with the property and suitable evidence must be shown.
Must a trust agreement always be made before a notary?
The requirement of written proof and the requirement of a notarial act are not the same. The content and signature of the document and the nature of the relationship are assessed separately; the formal transfer of title is a different matter.
Is a WhatsApp message enough to recover the title?
Depending on its circumstances, it may constitute initial written evidence and can be supplemented by witnesses. No single message is considered sufficient on its own.
Does a bank receipt prove a fiduciary transfer?
It may show the payment. Why that payment led to a registration in another person's name and to a duty to return must be proven separately.
What can be done if the original of the contract is with the defendant?
The document may be specified and its production requested under HMK Articles 219–220. The consequence of a failure to produce it is assessed by the court under the statutory conditions.
Does the limitation period always start from the transfer of title?
No. For a personal claim to re-transfer, the maturity of the claim, the conditions of the agreement and the time from which the duty to return could be demanded are what matter.
Can I recover the title I gave as security without paying the debt?
The content of the agreement and the mutual performances are examined. If the re-transfer is conditional on payment of the debt, you may need to perform your own obligation or offer to do so in the appropriate manner.
If the property is sold to someone else, is only money claimed?
There is no single outcome in every case. The position of the subsequent buyer, their knowledge and the legal basis of the title claim are assessed, as is the monetary liability of the original debtor.
How Is a Cancellation and Registration of Title Action Based on a Fiduciary Transfer Filed?
First, the parties to the agreement to return, the property, the condition and the means of proof are identified. The action is filed after assessing together the competent court, the necessary parties and, where needed, a claim for the price.
Can a Fiduciary Transfer Be Proved by Witnesses?
It may be possible where there is initial written evidence under HMK Article 202, or where the statutory exceptions to proof by witnesses apply. The mere existence of witnesses is not enough in every file.
Does an Earlier Action to Annul a Disposition Prove a Fiduciary Transfer?
Not automatically. The legal subject and the standards of proof of the two actions differ. The decision of the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) of March 10, 2026 stresses this limit.
Can an Action Be Brought if the Company Has Been Struck Off the Commercial Register?
The company's capacity to be a party, the reason for deregistration and, where necessary, the revival procedure must be examined. The company's partners cannot claim the company's property in their personal names merely because they are partners.
How Many Years Is the Limitation Period in a Fiduciary Transfer Title Action?
For the contractual duty to return, the general ten-year limitation period is considered; the start often depends on maturity. The date of transfer is not an automatic starting point in every case.
Can a Claim for the Price Be Added Later to an Action for Cancellation of Title?
The HMK and the 2026 decision unifying case law on adding a new claim must be taken into account. Framing the claim in the alternative at the outset may be safer in many cases.
Can Evidence by Oath Be Used in a Fiduciary Transfer?
It is possible under the statutory conditions; however, the oath has limits as to the party, the subject and facts that are personal. It may not be possible to make the knowledge of a non-party about another agreement the direct subject of an oath.
Where Is a Cancellation and Registration of Title Action Based on a Fiduciary Transfer Filed in Antalya?
For a claim for cancellation and registration of title concerning the property itself, the exclusive jurisdiction of the court where the property is located under HMK Article 12 is examined. If the property is outside Antalya, the mere fact that a party or counsel is in Antalya does not give that court jurisdiction. For a purely personal claim for the price, the type of claim is assessed separately.
Sources and legal bases
1 — Law No. 6098 Turkish Code of Obligations (Türk Borçlar Kanunu), particularly Articles 19, 26–27, 97, 112, 146, 149 and 154.
2 — Law No. 4721 Turkish Civil Code (Türk Medeni Kanunu), particularly Articles 706, 716 and 1023–1025.
3 — Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber (Yargıtay 7. Hukuk Dairesi), December 12, 2024, E.2024/195, K.2024/5689, full text of the decision; electronic records and initial written evidence.
4 — Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber (Yargıtay 7. Hukuk Dairesi), June 4, 2024, E.2023/4141, K.2024/3183, text of the decision; sufficiency of evidence and oath. The 1947 principle on unification of case law referred to in the text is also applied through this decision.
5 — Court of Cassation 1st Civil Chamber (Yargıtay 1. Hukuk Dairesi), November 11, 2024, E.2024/4867, K.2024/6128, full text of the decision; original of the protocol and HMK Articles 219–220.
6 — Law No. 6100 on Civil Procedure (Hukuk Muhakemeleri Kanunu), particularly Articles 2, 12, 111, 125, 190, 199–203, 219–220, 225, 367 and 389–397.
7 — Grand General Assembly for Unification of Case Law of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay İçtihatları Birleştirme Büyük Genel Kurulu), May 8, 2026, E.2021/8, K.2026/1, Official Gazette (Resmî Gazete) June 30, 2026, No. 33296; published copy of the decision on the Union of Turkish Bar Associations website.
8 — Court of Cassation Decision Unifying Case Law (Yargıtay İçtihadı Birleştirme Kararı), February 5, 1947, E.1945/20, K.1947/6.
9 — Court of Cassation 1st Civil Chamber (Yargıtay 1. Hukuk Dairesi), March 10, 2026, E.2024/3158, K.2026/1907; written evidence of a trust agreement, a statement in an earlier file and HMK Article 202.
10 — Court of Cassation General Assembly of Civil Chambers (Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu), October 4, 2023, E.2021/1-223, K.2023/893.
11 — Law No. 6102 Turkish Commercial Code (Türk Ticaret Kanunu), provisions on the deregistration and revival of companies.